Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts from February, 2021

What is Money?

   This isn’t a blog full of philosophy. I'm not very good at that, after all. There is little else that drives proper philosophers mad as a Nartz person contextualising everything, which I do instinctively as an historian. In the time of what might come to be seen as a bitcoin bubble, however, it does make sense to think about all the people who have thought about money from high and low points. The list is illustrious—from St Paul and Geoffrey Chaucer calling the love of money the root of all evil, to Dostoyevsky, Jefferson, and Marx owing so many people money that they ended up hating it. Most critiques of money are actually critiques of the way that people behave with it and around it. This is something that David Orrell, playing to economists’ almost permanent envy of physics, has written about in his remarkable book Quantum Economics and The New Science of Money , in which he argues that money is best understood via quantum theory as something given form by what peop...

A short note on economic cycles and crashes

  The idea of Economic Cycles, which purport to show that the economy manifests cyclical behaviour which can be identified and predicted is of long provenance, having been suggested by the astronomer Herschel in 1800, and by the polymath Sismondi in 1819. Over the subsequent years, Robert Owen, Clement Jugler, William Jevons, Karl Marx, Joseph Schumpeter, the Rothschild family, Kuznets, Kondratiev, Raymond Wheeler, Alexander Chizvesky, Hyman Minsky, Robert Elliot and Milton Friedman amongst others have assumed or put forward specific forms of cycle. Economists are sometimes suspicious of the idea of cycles, just as historians are, because they seem to be produced by ‘physics envy’ whilst at the same time do not lend themselves to what might be called proper mathematical analysis (though they can encourage people to make up silly maths-based ratios and connections.) [1] However, traders and ‘quants’—financial analysts—do sometimes use them. Policy makers and journalists like Mins...

Geoffrey Keating (Seathrun Ceatinn), 1633

I first came across the 'complaint of Ceatinn' from 1633 in Declan Kiberd's Inventing Ireland . It is a defiant response to English colonialism and the state of Ireland during one of our many popular catastrophes and episodes of near extinction. Keating lays out the reasons why the Irish historian should remember his people, and notes the tension between the path of an elitist--he has, after all, seen books and earned credibility that others have not--and the wisdom and culture of the people who produced him. It's in my commonplace book, which someday I should place online, but I wanted more people to see it; Oir ataim asoda, agus drong diobh-san og; do chonnairc me agus tuigim primh-leabhair an tseanchusa, agus ni facadarsan iad, agus da bhfacdis, ni tuigfidhe leo iad. Ni ar fhuath nar ar ghradh droinge ar bioth seach a cheile, na ar fhuraileamh aon duine, na do shuil re socha d’fhail uaidh, chuireas romhan stair nah Eireann do schriobh, ach de bhri gur mheasas nar bh’...