Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Isolationism

Did any of FDR’s critics make an impact on the New Deal, and if so, how?

  What can be called the domestic presidency of Franklin Roosevelt, between 1933 and 1940, was highly controversial. Taking office in the midst of the crisis caused by the Great Depression, Roosevelt had no set plan bar to ‘try what worked.’ This led to swathes of dynamic policymaking at odds with the more conservative impression that Roosevelt had conveyed on the campaign trail, when those who were supporters of gold-backed stability might have sought reassurance from his words. It is also clearly the case that multiple members of Roosevelt’s ‘own class’ of monied and socially well- connected Americans based largely in New England cities might also have assumed that he would, as a person known to them, not fundamentally threaten their interests. In fact, Roosevelt embarked upon a policy of economic stimulation, demand management, and industrial regulation, which quickly created reactive criticism, both in the Supreme Court and outside. Thus, criticism ‘on the right’ can be dis...

Was Prohibition simply a failure?

  Prohibition in the United States was a product of two wars and protestant social reform. It had a substantial latent underside of anti-Irish, anti-German, and anti-Catholic support. Characterising it in such a way places it alongside campaigns against Mormon polygamy, prostitution, and immigration between the Civil War and the First World War. It has been viewed as seperable from the movement for female suffrage, which arose at mostly the same time and the coalition of support for which broadly overlapped with prohibition. The great historian Richard Hofstadter, in fact, called it a ‘ludicrous parody’ of social reform in 1955. Such an outlook also allows for the limited federal prohibition regulations of 1918 in the Wartime Prohibition Act to be seen as opening the door to a ‘constitutional blunder’ in 1919, when Nebraska ratified the prohibition amendment, leaving New York, Pennsylvania, New Mexico, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Nevada isolated. A standard narrative has develope...

Why did the United States reject the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 but accept Bretton Woods, the United Nations Organisation and NATO in 1944-9?

The United States’ traditional engagement with the world, since before Washington’s farewell address, was one of trade and self-interest, rather than isolationism properly speaking. This was consonant with its existence as a country tied into foreign trade, with a government funded by a tariff (which required rather than discouraged trade and the reinvestment of profits) but no large Navy. From the late nineteenth century, this had begun to change, and the parallel development of the Great White Fleet and a style of hemispheric engagement that blended the Monroe Doctrine with the Roosevelt Corollary encouraged America to begin to integrate with the world. This integration involved a failed attempt at Imperialism; the development of dollar diplomacy; mediation in the Russo-Japanese war; and Taft’s attempt to mediate in Balkan and East European disputes before 1914. It is not therefore surprising that the US rejected Versailles. The odd thing, given its history, is the acceptance o...