Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Great War

From my wordpress blog: Sinn Fein 1905-1919

  Radical Nationalism, the Great War, and Irish Independence   Sinn Fein (translated as ‘ourselves’) is the name of a variety of parties in Irish nationalist history which share a common tradition on the radical and violent side of Irish republicanism. The traditions which inform its existence include those of political terrorism and conspiracy and reach back through the Irish Republican Brotherhood, the Invincibles, the Fenians, and Young Ireland, as well as that of the rising of 1798. At the same time, the modern party describes itself as a democratic, socialist, and republican party and is the second party in the present northern Irish assembly.   The Sinn Fein tradition is notoriously fissile, emerging from different groups, giving rise to the modern Fianna Fail and Fine Gael in the Republic, and splitting to give rise the Worker’s Party in the north of Ireland in the 1970, and thence to the Democratic Left and Irish Republican Socialist Party. ‘SF’ has been a...

Why did the United States reject the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 but accept Bretton Woods, the United Nations Organisation and NATO in 1944-9?

The United States’ traditional engagement with the world, since before Washington’s farewell address, was one of trade and self-interest, rather than isolationism properly speaking. This was consonant with its existence as a country tied into foreign trade, with a government funded by a tariff (which required rather than discouraged trade and the reinvestment of profits) but no large Navy. From the late nineteenth century, this had begun to change, and the parallel development of the Great White Fleet and a style of hemispheric engagement that blended the Monroe Doctrine with the Roosevelt Corollary encouraged America to begin to integrate with the world. This integration involved a failed attempt at Imperialism; the development of dollar diplomacy; mediation in the Russo-Japanese war; and Taft’s attempt to mediate in Balkan and East European disputes before 1914. It is not therefore surprising that the US rejected Versailles. The odd thing, given its history, is the acceptance o...

Why did the United States adopt a policy of neutrality from 1914 to 1917?

The US policy of neutrality with regard to European disputes was not an innovation in 1914. Since George Washington, it had been the policy of the USA not to participate in European wars. From the Monroe Administration onward, the USA also held to a policy of precluding the intervention of non-American powers in hemispheric affairs. This policy had been strengthened by McKinley’s expulsion of Spain as an American power in the Spanish-American War, the Roosevelt Corollary, and Taft’s embrace of dollar diplomacy. It was not therefore surprising that the USA declined initially to be involved in a fratricidal conflict in Europe. After all, the policy of the United States had been to prevent intervention by Europe in their own Civil War, and immediately after in Mexico. On those odd occasions where the USA had been involved in world affairs, such as the negotiations between Russia and Japan to end their war in 1905, it had been as a neutral peacemaker. In the two decades before 1914, Am...