Why not just privatise universities?
British (certainly English) universities are in deep trouble. These troubles appear to stem from a variety of sources. Students are increasingly packed into classrooms with inadequate teaching materials and exposed to tired lecturers or teaching assistants, for instance. Expanded 'foundation' and foreign-language programmes hoover up students and then cruelly dump them once money has been extracted. Academics are notoriously underpaid. Even if they can raise their heads above huge amounts of pointless research, many academics have never had an original thought and react badly to any presentation of one. Debate amongst students and professors, and tolerance, and civility, has given way to indifference. It is only a matter of time until lawyers start inventing suits which will create a climate of samizdat fear and reinforce the chilling strictures of the professional left and the fogeyish right. And all the time, serious laboratories, libraries, and teaching facilities are shutting down. The respomse of many university administrations is to continue to bureaucratise, slice teaching, and press down upon a pool of desperate academics whose only fault was not being encouraged to be enterprising, which led lots into the position of holding onto a subject they love for dear life. And of course, any allegation of racism, sexism, sexual harassment, or incompetence leads to the unfair and destructive treatment of what dedicated teachers exist, usually by the professional left and their eager place-people. None of this has happened to me, by the way, but i have seen it time and again.
So, where do all these problems stem from? I wrote at the top a single source, and I meant it. They stem from government funding. The queen's shilling. The abrogation of independence, the committee thinking, the timidity, and the nonsense of the modern campus at least protect administrators and the worst sort of personality-damaged nerd from the fresh enterprising sector. This does exist, at the minute in a sort of shady half-world of tutorial colleges, foundations, and undergraduate study abroad programmes which have their own and complementary faults because they aren't always treated seriously by universities here.
Imagine what would happen, though, if universities were freed; if they had an endowment and were then sailed away to develop their own rules and their own structures. There would be failures; mergers; some scandals. Of course there would. There would be no uniformity of product. There would be different rules about access. Maybe a lifelong security would be difficult to come by, and scholars, teachers and administrators would have to become entrepreneurs or just be so good that they were looked after. But would disaster ensue?
For instance, one thing that might be expected to happen would be that degrees would become modular. It might be possible to swap modules between institutions. To get a degree over the course of years. Why should this mean, as is often feared by people in the academic sector in Britain, that this will mean a 'dumbing down'? Don't adults want to learn about teh renaissance, or businessmen about black holes? Intelligent people who are liberated from the idea that the only way to learn anything is to go to a bookstore once one is past a certain age might be expected only to pay for ideas and teaching of quality, and proper historians, philosophers and artists need fear nothing. Those interested in obscure and hermetically sealed debates conducted in arcane language may; but they are a blight on universities anyway.
I can't stress the idea that the market tests ideas enough. Einstein did his best work as a patent clerk, for instance. It is usually said that this was because the work was so boring that he had to focus on the ideas that won him fame, an academic seat, and the invitation to the Israeli presidency (as well as a chance to meet gorgeous women who actually admired his being a geek, like Marilyn Monroe). But as a slew of new biographies point out, the opposite may have been the case. Einstein's mind prospered because he had to test new ideas, for money, and apply physics daya after day with a proper schedule and a proper sense of engagement with the world. he wasn't hiding in a castle built to preserve the west when barabarians turned up along with the black death, or playing herman hesse's glass bead game; he was living by his mind. John Locke had to do the same when he got chucked out of Oxford, and Adam smith when he left university to do 'less drinking and more thinking'.
At the same time, market failures do happen. So foundations, colleges or universities that can protect and nurture their talent and not overload them with teaching are necessary. Some brilliant people are weird and shouldn't be let near young bodies or public transport. But such instiututions require talented and able administrators. The idea has grown up in england that such administrators should also be academics. I've always liked a different model--that highly able administrators with academic interests or credentials should be allowed to run things as managers. The nonsense arguments and screaming fits that proposition has resulted in! Reader, I understand why larry summers was met with screaming hyperventilating fits when he suggested at harvard that different people might be good at different things.
There are also too many young people at university doing things for the sake of it that don't improve them half as much as a job would. An interlocking series of prejudices and social problems have arisen; one, that higher education is a right; two, that that right is also a rite of passage for the middle class children of people of property and an entree for those who are not; three, that a degree leads to a job with the self-sustaining classes who are members of the english middle classes. This is all nonsense, or should be. A university should be a place that offers to improve the individual and allow the experience of the life of the mind to be enhanced. It won't be if it is forced into a false model.
Perhaps I have been a little spolit by the experience of the Middle Temple, my Inn of court. There, highly qualified barristers exist in a community. They live the life of the mind, but are only as good as their last few cases and the accompanying brief fees. They sustain a college of more intellectual excitement than in oxford; and serious masters of their craft give up weekend and evening after weekend and evening to offer their experience for free to those aspiring to join the community who put the work in. No money, no bar; no bar, no non-money community of minds. Not a paradox, unless you think that rich, state-funded institutions that manage to impoverish themselves financially and most people associated with them personally and intellectually are in any way the model of education.
Right, that's that off my chest. What about question two?.....
British (certainly English) universities are in deep trouble. These troubles appear to stem from a variety of sources. Students are increasingly packed into classrooms with inadequate teaching materials and exposed to tired lecturers or teaching assistants, for instance. Expanded 'foundation' and foreign-language programmes hoover up students and then cruelly dump them once money has been extracted. Academics are notoriously underpaid. Even if they can raise their heads above huge amounts of pointless research, many academics have never had an original thought and react badly to any presentation of one. Debate amongst students and professors, and tolerance, and civility, has given way to indifference. It is only a matter of time until lawyers start inventing suits which will create a climate of samizdat fear and reinforce the chilling strictures of the professional left and the fogeyish right. And all the time, serious laboratories, libraries, and teaching facilities are shutting down. The respomse of many university administrations is to continue to bureaucratise, slice teaching, and press down upon a pool of desperate academics whose only fault was not being encouraged to be enterprising, which led lots into the position of holding onto a subject they love for dear life. And of course, any allegation of racism, sexism, sexual harassment, or incompetence leads to the unfair and destructive treatment of what dedicated teachers exist, usually by the professional left and their eager place-people. None of this has happened to me, by the way, but i have seen it time and again.
So, where do all these problems stem from? I wrote at the top a single source, and I meant it. They stem from government funding. The queen's shilling. The abrogation of independence, the committee thinking, the timidity, and the nonsense of the modern campus at least protect administrators and the worst sort of personality-damaged nerd from the fresh enterprising sector. This does exist, at the minute in a sort of shady half-world of tutorial colleges, foundations, and undergraduate study abroad programmes which have their own and complementary faults because they aren't always treated seriously by universities here.
Imagine what would happen, though, if universities were freed; if they had an endowment and were then sailed away to develop their own rules and their own structures. There would be failures; mergers; some scandals. Of course there would. There would be no uniformity of product. There would be different rules about access. Maybe a lifelong security would be difficult to come by, and scholars, teachers and administrators would have to become entrepreneurs or just be so good that they were looked after. But would disaster ensue?
For instance, one thing that might be expected to happen would be that degrees would become modular. It might be possible to swap modules between institutions. To get a degree over the course of years. Why should this mean, as is often feared by people in the academic sector in Britain, that this will mean a 'dumbing down'? Don't adults want to learn about teh renaissance, or businessmen about black holes? Intelligent people who are liberated from the idea that the only way to learn anything is to go to a bookstore once one is past a certain age might be expected only to pay for ideas and teaching of quality, and proper historians, philosophers and artists need fear nothing. Those interested in obscure and hermetically sealed debates conducted in arcane language may; but they are a blight on universities anyway.
I can't stress the idea that the market tests ideas enough. Einstein did his best work as a patent clerk, for instance. It is usually said that this was because the work was so boring that he had to focus on the ideas that won him fame, an academic seat, and the invitation to the Israeli presidency (as well as a chance to meet gorgeous women who actually admired his being a geek, like Marilyn Monroe). But as a slew of new biographies point out, the opposite may have been the case. Einstein's mind prospered because he had to test new ideas, for money, and apply physics daya after day with a proper schedule and a proper sense of engagement with the world. he wasn't hiding in a castle built to preserve the west when barabarians turned up along with the black death, or playing herman hesse's glass bead game; he was living by his mind. John Locke had to do the same when he got chucked out of Oxford, and Adam smith when he left university to do 'less drinking and more thinking'.
At the same time, market failures do happen. So foundations, colleges or universities that can protect and nurture their talent and not overload them with teaching are necessary. Some brilliant people are weird and shouldn't be let near young bodies or public transport. But such instiututions require talented and able administrators. The idea has grown up in england that such administrators should also be academics. I've always liked a different model--that highly able administrators with academic interests or credentials should be allowed to run things as managers. The nonsense arguments and screaming fits that proposition has resulted in! Reader, I understand why larry summers was met with screaming hyperventilating fits when he suggested at harvard that different people might be good at different things.
There are also too many young people at university doing things for the sake of it that don't improve them half as much as a job would. An interlocking series of prejudices and social problems have arisen; one, that higher education is a right; two, that that right is also a rite of passage for the middle class children of people of property and an entree for those who are not; three, that a degree leads to a job with the self-sustaining classes who are members of the english middle classes. This is all nonsense, or should be. A university should be a place that offers to improve the individual and allow the experience of the life of the mind to be enhanced. It won't be if it is forced into a false model.
Perhaps I have been a little spolit by the experience of the Middle Temple, my Inn of court. There, highly qualified barristers exist in a community. They live the life of the mind, but are only as good as their last few cases and the accompanying brief fees. They sustain a college of more intellectual excitement than in oxford; and serious masters of their craft give up weekend and evening after weekend and evening to offer their experience for free to those aspiring to join the community who put the work in. No money, no bar; no bar, no non-money community of minds. Not a paradox, unless you think that rich, state-funded institutions that manage to impoverish themselves financially and most people associated with them personally and intellectually are in any way the model of education.
Right, that's that off my chest. What about question two?.....
Comments