
The Eurozone ought to break up
The euro is on the face of it, an undemocratic project. This is in the sense that a largely unaccountable international bank has been handed nominal control of interest rates and money in a huge swathe of continental Europe. This co-ordination of monetary policy has been tied to a relatively strict regime of floating exchange rates with no allowed exchange controls or intervention, no zone-wide tax system to redistribute money from richer to poorer areas, and no flexibility to allow inflation to edge up if growth or unemployment are worries.
Initially, the programme was invested with a certain amount of democratic accountability in theory in that fiscal policy, and the issuing of government debt was to be coordinated by governments that considered themselves responsible to their peoples. Quite how a political elite elected largely by forms of proportional representation that keep the same people and attitudes in charge all the time could come to view itself as democratic is one of those very European tales of recovery from the populism of fascists and the fear of communism that made much of euro land so frightened of the people actually coming up with their own ideas.
Monetary Unions are not necessarily undemocratic from the point of view of sovereignty either. There are two reasons for this. The example of the African Financial Community, the CFA illustrates one. Where one cannot trust governments, or where states are faced with irrelevance and domination by international banks, a common currency if organised properly, can enhance exchange rate stability, create a pressure against tax-funded or inflationary deficits, and 'pool' power for citizens who are not in control of their own destinies through isolated national governments. It can also create a powerful boost to regional trade if protected against great market swings.
The problem with the euro was that it was not properly organised. National governments could still issue bonds that have their own interest rates, which will be paid back by euros from the governments raised in taxes. That means that places like Italy, Belgium, Greece and France could issue bonds in euros but have higher rates than other states on the bonds, and when they paid back, could actually cause inflation by injecting money into the markets at the same time as they create slowdown or recession with taxes to pay for the bonds.If the rest of the zone wished to avoid this, the central bank would have to raise rates for everyone, thus slowing everyone down but causing the exchange rate to rise.This would worsen domestic trade and exports still further whilst raising imports and destabilising other currencies.
When other currencies are living in an Edward Munch lalaland, as the dollar currently is, and when capital is looking for an excuse to flow to the pound or the far east, and when good old-fashioned inflationary shock from oil and wheat is in the offing, this situation could get even worse.
When this is accompanied by Arab and Venezuelan and Iranian pressure to price oil in euros, which would push the euro up even more, and Chinese, Korean and Japanese suspicion of the dollar, this situation would become unsustainable without some sort of common tax and spend policy in Europe plus a slashing of government deficits, which will not happen.
So,the obvious solution is for Euro land political elites to dust down the story of the nineteenth century Latin Monetary Union or the more contemporary story of the ERM. They could even take a page from the later Roman Empire. They could split the euro zone into a German and a Latin half.
If that did not work they could contemplate restoring national currencies.
If neither happens, Britain will face an inflow of inflationary funds at the same time as a rise in basic prices and a slowdown in growth--leading to a stagflation and then the mother of all recessions. Not even the IMF will be able to help.
So, Cheers everyone--it's back to 1975-7 in the New Year!
Comments