Easter Sunday is not known
as Resurrection Day, as I understand it, in any European language. Some
American Protestants take a literal approach to Easter (which functions on
something of a Pagan palimpsest) and reject the festival, preferring to emphasise
the continuing effect of resurrection. The ‘day of resurrection’ is a synonym
in the rest of Christendom for the Day of Judgment. In this the fundamentalists
and literalists parallel the Islamic perspective, since the followers of the
Koran talk of al-Qiyamah as Judgement Day, but not of anything comparable to
Easter Sunday. Presumably, though they do not apply it to Jesus, the Muslims do
therefore have a concept of a resurrection, just not of that of Christ. That
written, I’ve only ever come across Shia who believe in dormition, at most—not actual
death and regeneration.
Catholic and Orthodox
Christianity, as well as Coptic Tributaries quite rightly focus on the day of
Christ’s Resurrection as the centre of the faith beyond history. This raises a
number of logical problems. Once the resurrection happens, humanity is saved.
It represents a new covenant, to replace those of Adam, Isaac, Noah, Job, and
David, inter alia. It seems to amend that between Moses and God as recorded in the second set of commandments brought from the mountaintop. Deal 8.0 if you will. As St Augustine realised, this poses
no issue; the new covenant stretches back and forward and everywhere in time.
In essence, it eliminates history and makes the passion of Jesus the centre of
time; indeed, in a way it makes it time itself. Bishop Berkeley-like, we can
only have spiritual consciousness in the world that the resurrection has
created. It is always resurrection day.
However, the world we live
in does have a beginning and will have an end. Before the passion, there was
one world; after there is another. That world has no beginning and no end, yet
History unfolds and in that sense progresses. Cycles may exist within it, but
things change and their pattern of growth or mutation can be identified and in
many cases lessons can be learned from that trend. Like Adam and Eve being
expelled from the Garden, because they now have knowledge, we live in moments
of History.
From the observation of that which we perceive to exist, other people end, so we will. We began. So they did. If we can't trust our observations, we fall back onto a sort of Cartesian phenomenology; there was a time when we did not think, there could be a time when we do not, and both precepts depend upon memory, which is a word for internal history. So everything rests on history except either the things that we know instinctively, and the things that we can prove logically. This is where St Anselm fits in, with an elegant proof that thought itself must lead to God since we can envisage a supreme thing, and a supreme thing would exist, so the supreme thing must exist.
What if you reject your senses, your sense of self, and logic? Well, physics hints at either platonic truths in the underlying maths, or multiple worlds. If defined against either, we live in history.
Jesus does that, too. Christ does
not. Christ exists at all points if the resurrection is true. The resurrection is outside history.
Within the passion, Jesus demonstrates numerous responses, from anger, bargaining, acceptance, conciliation and revolt. He changes up to that point. But when the Christ side of his nature becomes evident, everything changes to become the same--ἀνάστασις. Everything stands. Forever.
That's one of the central mysteries of life--the central mystery, if you will, of all life.
Within the passion, Jesus demonstrates numerous responses, from anger, bargaining, acceptance, conciliation and revolt. He changes up to that point. But when the Christ side of his nature becomes evident, everything changes to become the same--ἀνάστασις. Everything stands. Forever.
That's one of the central mysteries of life--the central mystery, if you will, of all life.
The metaphysics of it all are flawless, and going further probably
passes over the requirement that we not try to put the ocean in a cup or to ‘second
guess’ God. Still, it seems to have taken three hundred years for what happened
to be defined. The passage of another seventeen hundred has elaborated things
further in the deposit of faith, but we are still accommodating changes in
interpretation and a turning world is still experiencing material progress.
So how do we live in change and in the light of an unchanging truth? I’ve not gone Arian but this seems to me
to be one of the most fundamental questions of Western history, and it rings
through most of our ideologies and conceptual schemes. We’re taught, for
instance, that political ideologies are all rooted in views of human nature.
Some people believe humans to be rational; others emphasise individualism;
others look to how we live in tradition; and a further strain views us as
collectively defined. The new-old combination of paganism and systems theory
that makes up Greenery sees us as a part of the environment. This diversity of
views of what we are is why we have numerous and irreconcilable isms, from liberalism,
conservatism, and socialism.
We also elaborate these
views and then confuse the mechanisms we develop a view of—like choice, or
scientific falsifiability, or naturalist 0ntologies—with proof. By these means
our ideas gain as great an apparent life as people in our minds and outlooks.
We can never, however, be satisfied with any of them, for reasons I’ll go into
in a separate post. For all our attempts to elaborate, these attempts at proof
do not feed our need for faith, and nor do they explain our relationship to
time. We know we that we change; we know that times change. Some of us
associate this progress with moral growth. Many don’t. Many believe that we
stay the same through life. Some don’t.
So we struggle. We look for
objective points of reference that can’t change, or in their absence cognitive
systems that process the changing world whilst staying the same. We all have
some shadow of the resurrection event by which we define ourselves. Yet we
believe in subjective experience of movement and development, a beginning and
an end. Eastern mystics are often misunderstood in this regard. It isn’t that
they want to lose themselves in inexplicable parts of themselves. Only the Western narcissist
playing with Orientalism believe that. True mystics want to find the source of
their demons, the confusion arising from contorted limitations within themselves,
and explore their souls in order to change those limitations with newer and presumably
truer parameters. They do set lines and they do come back. Nirvana is a great
idea but it noticeably comes after life.
I think that this struggle
between the wish to acknowledge things or tools that do not change and the
knowledge that most things do is Western. I think that for several reasons. It
seems a logical outgrowth of what one could call omnipotent monotheism, which
is a Judaeo-Christian thing. I can also point to fractal evidence throughout
Western, or at a pinch, Christian, culture. Thirdly, I don’t really know enough
about the Eastern or Southern peoples of the Earth to make statements about the
cultures prevailing amongst such folk.
On this Easter Sunday, I
find myself wondering if it’s this tension, this outlook, which motivates those
who are clinging to the dollar-based world, to fundamentalist views of the
Constitution of the United States, or to a comforting hard-line return to
basics when both Christendom and the Dar-al-Islam seem in any reasonable
perspective to be in a state of narrative collapse. See, it solves a puzzle for
me which is a perennial one. The puzzle is why people won’t look through their
numerous idolatries and consensus wisdoms and actually grasp what seems obvious
in the political and economic world, and do something about it.
The explanation that we are
all distracted just won’t cut it. Nor, though, do I want the subjective and
reliably false thrill of thinking that I get something that other people don’t
about ongoing civilizational decline. I’m not alone and I have no special
insight. Why, though, is my predictable outlook nevertheless unusual? Why won’t
people see where we are and where we are obviously headed? Is it that the
tension between the West’s four vectors—what always was, what has been and will
be, ‘I’ and ‘We’—just confuses us and overwhelms our ears? Or is it that, like
St Peter in the water, the only one who can rescue us, striding across the
waves, is the one we will inevitably deny; Alpha and Omega, East and West—Jesus
and Christ?
Comments