The
Irish Parliament 1297-1800
There
was a semi-autonomous Irish parliament between 1297 and 1800. From 1537, this
body was divided into an Irish House of Lords and House of Commons on an highly restricted franchise, and whereas it
purported to a national authority, it should not be misinterpreted as a
national assembly. From 1495, its laws had to be cleared by the Irish and
British Privy Councils, for instance, as ‘Ponying’s Law’ subordinated the Irish
parliament to the English one.[1]
From
1607, in the wake of the Gunpowder Plot, until 1778, Catholics in Ireland were
excluded at various times from public office, voting, the army, many forms of
ownership, and effectively from public worship and burial. This process was
from time to time interrupted, and was not systematic at first, leaving some
Irish catholic lords and MPs until the late seventeenth century, for instance.
From the early seventeenth century, however, constituencies were changed to
give the Irish House of Commons a protestant majority, and from 1613, the
Plantation of Ulster was ongoing. This meant that colonisation by Scottish
Protestants of that province was encouraged.
From
the late sixteenth century through to 1607, Gaelic people were characterised as
backward savages.[2]
The British Civil Wars, when Irish Catholics and the remaining Gaels were
associated in the Kilkenny Confederation, deepened this ‘othering.’ The 1640s
saw ‘Confederate Ireland’ allied with the Stuarts against the murderous
protestant forces of Oliver Cromwell and the English Commonwealth, and
incidentally therefore against the Irish Parliament.[3]
Cromwell
managed to defeat the alliance, and then the confederation, and complete
exclusion of Catholics proceeded until the Commonwealth itself collapsed in
1660, when the Restoration reset relations in Ireland and restored parliamentary
authority on both sides of the Irish Sea, though on a protestant-majority
basis. This situation was again reversed by the fall of the Stuarts in 1688-91,
and although King William was in effect allied to the papacy, his policies and
circumstances inevitably caused him to come into conflict with most Irish
people. This was because the coup of 1688-9 was in effect a Protestant
consolidation of the English state which then moved aggressively to dominate
and pacify the British Isles.
The
story of the eighteenth century is a complicated one, and summaries are always
of course dangerous. It is fair to say, however, that the strengthening of the
English-backed state in Ireland, represented by the parliament, the defeat of
the Gaels, and with tolerance only extended to Catholic aristocrats who were
prepared to swear loyalty oaths, suppressed the development of the Irish middle
class. The gentry, such as it was, was governed by the vigorous extraction of
rents and surpluses by the Irish aristocracy, which drove a lot of the middle
classes out to America. This is why the bulk of Irish emigration over the past
three hundred years to North America has been protestant, though Irish American
protestants have tended to call themselves Scots-Irish rather than Irish.
The
modern American and British states were forged in the heat of the French
Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars. By the 1790s, this pressure was temporarily
strengthening the Irish parliament under Henry Grattan, who from 1782 had moved
to reclaim authority and autonomy. In the 1790s, this meant repeal of Catholic
exclusion, and the enfranchisement of Catholics.
Two
events, sadly, served to compromise this ‘Irish Patriot’ agenda in the eyes of
the Parliament at Westminster. One was a pre-emptive offer to Prince George in
1789 to become Regent of Ireland on the part of the Irish Parliament. The
Regency was envisaged as a response to the illness of George III. The offer
occurred before the creation of a Regency in England and upset those who
believed that the British Parliament (England and Scotland had merged their
parliaments in 1707); it was also ill-timed, as George III recovered before it
could be enacted.
A
second, and more serious event, was an attempted revolution with French aid in
1798. This was of a piece with continental and American revolutionary efforts,
in that it envisaged the rule of the secular, republican United Irish movement.
The ‘rebellion’ was defeated, but from 1798 on, George III, Prime Minister
Pitt, and key members of the English governing class were convinced that the
Irish state and parliament were too corrupt, too unpopular, and too
fundamentally weak to secure ‘England’s back door.’
The
British leaders therefore proceeded, along with Lord Cornwallis (who was
appointed Lord Lieutenant, or Governor, of Ireland) to undermine the Irish
Parliament and to attempt to win over Irish Anglican Bishops, Lords, and MPs,
to the idea of a Union with Westminster. Notably, a small group of middle-class
barristers, amongst who Daniel O’Connell was prominent, opposed the loss of
self-government. That small group, however, found it almost impossible to argue
with the indifference of most Irish people to the parliament as it stood, and
with Pitt’s embrace of Irish catholic emancipation. Pitt could not gain the
support of his fellow ministers for such emancipation, and so resorted to
bribery and patronage to win over Irish decision makers.
The
effort worked. On 2 July 1800, the Act of Union passed through the British
Parliament, having been previously passed by the Irish one, and was given Royal
Assent on August 1. On August 2, 1800, the Irish Parliament met for the last
time. From 1 January 1801, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland,
under the United Kingdom Parliament, ruled the British Isles.
The
Problem with the UK
The
United Kingdom was created by Acts of Parliament in both countries. It did not
create a written constitution, but in line with British and English practice,
it incorporated key constitutional conventions and a social regime which were
based around the idea of the absolute sovereignty of the Crown-in-Parliament.
For those in the new parliament, liberty, the virtues consequent upon
Protestantism, their property, and the growing prosperity and power of the
British Empire, were based around the existence of the sovereign parliament.
Parliament,
which produced the supreme law of the state, could do anything-- except bind a
future parliament. It could not limit itself, though it might adopt procedures
that fitted with the unwritten constitutional code. It could also not dissolve
itself, and, it was widely believed, it could not delegate its power to
legislate to any other body. If it did devolve or delegate its powers, these
could be captured by ministers and their supporters, effectively undermining
parliament, and might even encourage ministers to use royal forms of lawmaking
and judicial enquiry to undermine Parliament.
It
is important to note this confluence of constitutionalism and self-interest in
the UK Parliament’s claim to absolute sovereignty in the mystical union of
crown and people in parliament. Over time, this was to evolve as a rule to
effectively become an assumption that the House of Commons represented the
Sovereign people, as well as the Crown, and that government was synonymous with
the rule of law. Ministers had to be accountable members of either house, and the monarch was separate from the crown. In a
sense, this settlement should not have surprised any observer of the American
revolution; parliament had in those circumstances, after all, rejected an
achievable peace based on the idea of sharing power or position with colonial
legislatures, and had ultimately let the colonies go rather than compromise
(aided by military defeat at the hands of France and its allies in North
America.)
For
the first decades of the nineteenth century, the idea of Catholic emancipation
and the development of the new British state, and its relationship with Africa
and Asia, dominated parliament. As the industrial revolution progressed, new
Conservative and Liberal parties emerged to replace the old Whig and Tory
factions, and the Irish question became one of land reform and the emancipation
of British subjects, The disaster of the Famine, and the rise of a ‘Home Rule’
movement alongside a violent and organised campaign of the global Irish against
British control of Ireland changed politics.
Unfortunately,
the campaign for a restored Irish Parliament, under an Irish Home Rule Party
which stood for elections in Westminster, coincided with a new Victorian
Anglo-Saxon racism and an Anglo-American racial categorisation of the ‘native
Irish’ and Catholicism which poisoned a great many against Home Rule.[4]
This was accompanied by the elaboration of the doctrine of parliamentary
sovereignty by Alexander Venn Dicey and Walter Bagehot in a way that made
‘devolution’ a contested constitutional doctrine. The efforts of William
Gladstone, Liberalism’s greatest leader of the period, to promote Irish Home
Rule split his party, and caused the emergence of a new, pro-Empire, anti-Irish
Home Rule Party, the Liberal Unionists. Liberal Unionists, allied to
Conservatives, then edged out Liberals plus the independent Irish Party in the
politics of the later nineteenth century. During this process, the protestant
majority of four of the ten counties of the Northern province of Ulster became
more and more hostile to ‘Dublin rule’ which they associated with theocracy and
Anglophobic agrarian nationalism.
This
discontent, which was exploited by the British Conservative Party and a local
lawyer, Edward Carson, and which was reflected in opinion in the armed forces
and establishment, ultimately led to the establishment in 1922 of a
self-governing British jurisdiction in six counties of Ulster termed ‘Northern
Ireland.’
The
Issues in Summary
The
cause of Irish Home Rule raised a problem for parliamentary supremacy, in that the
creation of a devolved assembly on the island of Ireland with law-making powers
pleased some nationalists, but echoed the old, discredited Irish Parliament to
others who preferred a republican sovereignty.
The
UK was also faced with the likelihood by the late nineteenth century of armed
rebellion by a pro-British group in the north of Ireland with settler values
which would become typical of others around the Empire as decolonisation and
majority rule began to be contemplated, particularly in Africa. In addition,
self-government for Ireland challenged a racial order and had implications for
Home Rule in India, which after an attempted war of independence in 1857, was
governed by a British ‘Raj’ not dissimilar to the British rule in Ireland.
From
the 1840s., British politicians and public opinion had also become inimical to
the existence of a violent, global conspiracy directed at a republican
settlement in Ireland and funded and staffed largely by American Irish elements.
This coincided with Victorian anticatholicism, a Celtic literary and
intellectual revival, and British political splits after the Irish famine and
mass Irish emigration to England, America, and the colonies, to make the Irish
issue a particularly difficult one to clarify and solve.
[1] For most of the past eight
hundred years, Privy Councils have functioned as a kind of executive council
for the monarch. The Privy Council is a body which still exists ‘to advise the Sovereign.’
It acknowledges the accession of any new monarch, membership is guarded by an
oath of secrecy and discretion which has held with almost no breaches for
centuries, and its committees and orders can have constitutional significance.
For instance, for most of the duration of the British Empire, and in a few
remaining instances the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in the UK
(composed of senior Judges known as the Law Lords) was the final court of
appeal for many colonies and former colonies. Appointment is generally for life, and can
extend to any senior politician or member of the ‘establishment,’ indicated by
the title ‘The Right Honourable’ before their names. Ministers who are members
of the Council can issue ‘orders-in-council’ which correspond to executive
orders in other systems.
[2] This point has been recognised for more than an hundred years: see,
for instance, E.D. Snyder’s 1920 article, “The Wild Irish: A Study of Some
English Satires against the Irish, Scots, and Welsh”, Modern Philology
Vol 17 No 12 (Apr 1920) pp687-925. More modern studies, such as those of Bruce
Nelson in Irish Nationalists (2012) have noted the clear line between Geraldus
Cambrensis in the twelth century, who characterised the Gaels as ‘beasts’
through Shakespeare’s association in As You Like It of the Irish with a
talkativeness that could kill rats (As You Like It 3.2.177) to Edmund
Spenser’s view that the Gaelic Irish peasantry should be starved by famine out
of existence. These views, reinforced in the early modern period by the penal
laws, meshed with ‘scientific’ racism and Anglo-Saxonism from the 1840s onwards.
[3] Cromwell’s position in
British history is very ambiguous. He led the only (openly) regicide government
in modern English history, was a kind of president of England’s only Republic
between 1649 and 1661 (along with his son) and, despite assaulting and dismissing
parliament, is often seen as a defender of the parliamentary principle of self-government
against the Crown. In Ireland, he is remembered for a campaign of massacre
domination, and religious oppression in the epithetic description ‘Bloody Old Cromwell
and his murderous crew,’ not least in popular songs such as ‘West of the Old
River Shannon,’ (
[4] This process took
place between 1870 and 1882, as Home Rule proceeded from an Association (1870)
to a League (1873) to a Parliamentary Party (1882.) The rise of the Party and
its adoption of blocking and delaying tactics of parliamentary procedure enticed
the Liberal Party under William Gladstone into a proposal for a devolved parliament
in Ireland over the course of 1885-6. This delivered the Liberals the
government, but the effort to pass an Home Rule Bill split the Liberal
Unionists away, and caused the government to fall. A second attempt at Home
Rule was made by Gladstone, once again PM, in 1893, which passed the Commons
but fell in the Lords. The Third Home Rule Bill was again passed by the Commons
in 1912, vetoed by the Lords in 1912, 13, and 14, and eventually passed by the
Commons in 1914 under the Parliament Act. It was then superseded by the Great
War, and ultimately the Fourth Home Rule Bill passed in 1920. This was in turn
displaced by the events of the Irish Revolution and Treaty which recognised the
Irish Free State in 1922 after the Treaty of 1921.
Comments