Skip to main content

From My wordpress Blog: Terence O' Neill and the Irish Troubles

 

“...And the North is full of tangled things, and texts, and aching eyes,

And dead is all the innocence of anger and surprise;

And Christian killeth Christian in a narrow dusty room,

And Christian dreadeth Christ that hath a newer face of doom;

And Christian hateth Mary, whom God kissed in Galilee....”

G.K.Chesterton, Lepanto, 1915

 

Of the four Ulster Unionist Premiers between 1921 and 1969, two enjoyed a very long period in office, once they had secured their position. The third, Sir Basil Brooke, served from 1943-1963, and the first, Lord Craigavon, served from 1921-1940.  The second and fourth are in that regard interesting, in the sense that they could not hold their positions for very long. In the case of JM Andrews (the second premier, between 1940 and 1943) this was because he was in fact very old, and had such a longstanding position in the north that he found it very difficult to fire the friends he had appointed to government. Given that they were incompetents who presided at a time when bombing and the suspicion that the north was on offer to the republic (which it was) by the British, this plus by-election defeats caused Andrews to be ejected as Prime Minister.

Sir Terence O’Neill, the fourth premier from 1963 to 69, was a different type of person. He had been born with an aristocratic pedigree in London, at a house just off Hyde Park, and was educated at Eton before becoming a distinguished tank commander in the second world war (in which both his brothers died.) His father was the first member of parliament to be killed on military duty in the Great War, and O’Neill spent summers in Ulster as a boy at his late father’s home. In 1946, he and his wife moved back to Ulster, and O’Neill rose rapidly through Ulster politics to enter the cabinet an hold high office between 1956 and 1963, when he became Prime Minister.

O’Neill, though a member of the Orange Order, did not get along with Ulster Unionists of the sectarian sort, which was almost all of them. He believed in a non-sectarian and British future for the North and was not blind to the entrenched cultural division and domination of Catholics by the orange state (though he did not seek to change the electoral system back to the proportional representation which had prevailed until 1929.) He did seek to work with unions to modernise the Ulster economy, to end sectarian division, and reached out to the Taoiseach, Sean Lemass in the South. When he invited Lemass to Stormont for talks in 1965, there was outrage from the more ‘democratic’ unionists. Some of the latter physically attacked MPs who supported O’Neill, and, under the guidance of the reverend Ian Paisley, threw snowballs at Lemass’ car on its arrival in Ulster.

O’Neill, despite being a moderniser, was an instinctive if liberal Tory. Harold Wilson in London, who by 1966 was growing more and more suspicious of his own security services and their Ulster sensitivities, was not a wholly reliable ally; indeed, Wilson, who represented a very Catholic part of Liverpool from time to time preferred to promote the Northern Ireland Labour party (Liverpool retains the distinction of being the only part of Great Britain to have had an Irish nationalist MP, as TP O’Connor sat for the Home Rule Party and then as an independent there from 1880 until 1929.) This, and his own isolation, put pressure on O’Neill to move perhaps more quickly than his Unionist brethren would accept, though a significant section resisted all change at all times in any event and were bitterly anticatholic.

The actions of the Northern Ireland premier in 1967 and early 1968, in which he recognised the civil rights association as having legitimate grievances, got him pelted with eggs and condemned by his own side in May 1968 (on the pretext of his ‘working with’ the new Irish leader, Jack Lynch.) On October 5 1968, the Royal Ulster Constabulary responded to one civil rights meeting with great violence, leading to televised pictures of a ‘police riot.’ This in turn caused a reaction from Harold Wilson, who summoned O’Neill to Downing Street and read the riot act, threatening to ‘take over’ Ulster if O’Neill could not establish control and community cooperation.

O’Neill was thus premier at an exceptionally difficult time. The north was as subject to the effects of the radical, youth-driven wave of political protest as the rest of the post-war world was in the nineteen sixties and was also ill-suited to ride it out. By 1967, its parliament and councils had been transformed into gerrymandered Unionist bastions, and the political attitudes of its population were rooted elsewhere, as well as the past. To Catholics forced into the functional equivalent of ghettoes in crowded housing, whilst new builds were denied to them, separated from good jobs and personal security by invisible walls, the history of Gaelic and catholic exclusion in Ireland was evident in every single interaction with the state.

In the parallel world of working- and middle-class protestants (two different places, really) colours, statues, and references, and even Easter lilies (let alone Poppies) evoked a different history, one of siege, defiance, and deliverance in the face of conspiracy and fascism. Such states do not fall when times are rough; they fall when incomes are rising and there is at least the realistic possibility of change.

The global nineteen sixties were such a period. Multiple influences played around the mental worlds of people in the north in the decade. From Rome, the effects of the second Vatican Council rolled through churches, removing latin, changing the mass, and unsettling many. In response, the papacy of Paul VI rolled back a little, tacking towards conservatism in the matter of contraception and sexual identity just as the secular world went the other way.

 In Britain, though the country had enjoyed a burst of self-confidence and post-Suez renewal under successive governments, things were coming apart by 1967. Demented media barons such as Cecil King were roping establishment figures into ‘dotty’ coup attempts, agitated by the collapse of the pound on international markets in 1967. The remaining ‘white colony’ of Rhodesia had walked out of its relationship with Britain, just as immigration-related protest, strikes, and inflation began to hit at a home country experiencing the first waves of radical feminism and a diminished role in the world, which popular culture was determinedly denying in wave after wave of exaggerated patriotic films that were flecked with paranoia about communism and threats to the British way of life, as evident in the Daleks as Bond films.

America, simply speaking, went mad at some point around 1966. This was important for the mental worlds of people on the island of Ireland, as so much hope and tension had been projected onto the USA by the families left behind after waves of emigration to America over the previous two hundred years. Vietnam, the civil rights protests, the intimate betrayals and Byzantine drama of American politics, and the shooting down of remaining promise by a succession of dubious alleged assassins were engraved into Irish minds as surely as much as Latin grammar and the Bible once had been. American reporting methods and technology, in a reciprocal act, were now capable of bringing the reality of the north to American and British homes, unsettling the unionist ascendancy and conveying an immediate virtue to the nationalist cause whether associated with men of honour like John Hume or angry semi-Maoist radicals in balaclavas.

In this environment, Terence O’Neill, to his immense credit, asked the right questions. He challenged the north, via television and speeches, to be better than a narrow sectarian state, emphasising, neither for the first nor the last time, that the province could mark out a tolerant and economically privileged future if it were nimble enough to modernise and to embrace toleration and a creative balance between communities. O’Neill pointed to the technological, industrial, and agricultural potential of his small state, and hinted at how it could have become a western version of the celtic tiger before anyone coined the term. All unionists needed to do, he claimed, was to embrace change, their fellow citizens, and to have the courage to reform.

To many unionists, this was fantasy. When they looked South, they saw a semi-fascist backwater ruled by an Anglophobic agrarian theocracy who comfortably harboured former Nazis and a Dublin elite who seemed to want to be French.[1] To them, a northern state not absolutely committed to the politics and culture of unionism was as absurd as a non-Jewish Israel. Moreover, such a place would be a land in which the homes, schools, jobs and physical security of a people which had convinced itself that only it had sacrificed and fought in the world wars would be lost to the demographic expansion of the servants of Romanism.  The more middle-class unionists educated in the north’s excellent grammar schools tended not to express such views but did join the orange order in large numbers and did not condemn Ian Paisley outright when he came out with such sentiments. In many cases, they simply left when they came of age. This was at least one thing connecting them with many Catholics.

Under O’Neill, however, things came to a boil. In the summers of the late sixties and early seventies, the Northern Ireland civil rights association (NICRA) challenged the northern state again and again, and each time, the ‘B-Special’ auxiliaries of the Royal Ulster Constabulary disgraced themselves. This revolutionary moment was now televised and placed great pressure on men like James Callaghan as Home Secretary between 1967 and 1970, and Edward Heath as Prime Minister thereafter, which almost guaranteed a British state response. Wilson sent in British troops following the August riots in Derry in 1969, six months after O’Neill fell and at the pro forma request of his successor, but Heath and Callaghan were far tougher men than Wilson, who tended towards wartime memories of wielding physical power confidently and firmly.

The intervention, codenamed between 1969 and 2007 as Operation Banner, was the product of the sequence of events in 1969. At the start of the year, as people of Irish descent in other countries prepared to go to the moon, O’Neill attempted to persuade his party to accept a basic package of human freedoms which did not even challenge resistance to the concept of one person one vote in local elections. This caused immense trouble within the formerly monolithic Ulster Unionist party. Simultaneously, a civil rights march led by young university educated radicals was attacked by unionist ‘civilians’ whilst the police stood aside, provoking riots in the Catholic bogside area of Derry.  In response, O’Neill called an election for the provincial government in February (following renewed Civil rights demonstrations in January) in which his party split apart, nominally over his existence. 

During the general election, O’Neill was challenged directly as a candidate by the Reverend Paisley, who came close to winning and whose small margin of defeat had more or less the same effect as that of Eugene McCarthy on Lyndon Johnson in New Hampshire the year before. When the same sort of unionists as those who had supported Paisley and attacked the January marchers claimed responsibility for bombing the Belfast Water supply later in April, having lost his majority, O’Neill resigned.

This brought in another Etonian (and Sandhurst officer) James Chichester Clark, for whom O’Neill cast the deciding vote as Prime Minister on the basis that he had been ‘less of a disloyal backstabber’ than the other candidate, Brian Faulkner. Faulkner was also one of the bloc of working-class unionists who sat with difficulty in the official UUP, and who would later constitute the core of the Paisleyite Democratic Unionists.  It was Clark who asked the British for assistance in 1969, Clark who accepted the O’Neillite recommendations of the Cameron and Hunt Commissions that the B-Specials be disbanded and sectarianism be tackled, and, consequently, Clark who was in turn shunted asideby Edward Heath in 1971 as the provisional IRA began the targeted murders of off-duty soldiers.

Clark’s name is associated with an increasing spiral of violence in the north, when the British army went from an initial welcome to an almost inevitable antagonism with catholic and nationalist youths and the inhabitants of Derry. This process, in which riots and violence were gradually normalised, led to Chichester-Clark and his government being forced to accept the takeover of Northern security by the Army Command, and his gradual and frequent humiliation by Heath and the media. Following his resignation in March 1971, Clark was replaced by Brian Faulkner, and then, in time, the vortex of bloodshed overwhelmed Stormont.

The road was paved with three operations which were really driven by the Crown, in the form of the Army and Westminster, but supported by unionists: Operations Demetrius, Motorman, and Bloody Sunday.  Demetrius, which marked the return of internment and coercion, took place in August 1971; Bloody Sunday was in January 1972, and Motorman, in which the Army took on the Provisional IRA and attempted to restore British rule to Catholic ‘Free’ Derry, in July 1972.

The turmoil on the unionist side, largely reflected in the political manoeuvrings within and between Belfast and London, was reflected in developments elsewhere, which would affect both contemporaries and the future half century of Irish and British politics. Within republicanism, the official IRA and Sinn Fein split, giving rise to three new political parties (Provisional Sinn Fein, the Worker’s Party, and the later Irish Republican Socialist Party) and the core of two paramilitary groups, the provisional IRA and, later in the seventies, the Irish National Liberation Army (INLA.) The splits did not happen all at once and have a complex history of their own, but they fit with the general disorder of the decade, which fell year after year into more and more political and economic dislocation.

On the centre and moderate left, the Troubles, as they had already come to be known, gave rise to the Social Democratic and Labour Party in 1970, as the Nationalist, Republican Labour, Democratic, and Labour Parties coalesced.  The SDLP despite assaults from paramilitaries on both sides, prevailed as the majority nationalist party until the mid-2000s, when it slipped behind Sinn Fein and came to be seen as a middle-class Catholic party. Similarly, a small O’Neillite protestant and middle-class movement, the Alliance Party, emerged as a cross-party liberal group also emerged in 1970, and in the 2010s has become a significant if small ‘fifth party’ in northern politics.

So, by 1970, the scene was set. The decade was, in Irish politics, one of extraordinary resilience and change; but it was also to become one of the most soul-destroying in Anglo-Irish history.



[1] To be fair, Oswald Mosley, the leader of Britain’s Fascist movement in the nineteen thirties and forties, had lived quite comfortably with his wife just outside the Curragh in Kildare, having moved from Clonfert where the Bishop’s Palace he occupied burnt down. In 1952, the Westmeath Independent newspaper described the putative Anglo-Fuhrer as ‘the former leader of a political movement in England.’ In return, Mosley conceded in his memoirs that whilst he had time for Hitler and admired Mussolini, David Lloyd George and the Black and Tans were a disgrace. Otto Skorzeny (Hitler’s favourite Commando) had also kept a house in Ireland, as had the war criminal Pieter Menten in Waterford. Andrija Artukovic, the ‘Butcher of the Balkans’ when Nazi Interior Minister in Croatia, was a regular attendee at mass in Rathgar, Dublin, where he lived after 1947, and Celestin Laine, the ntorious leader of a Waffen SS execution gang, developed his ideas on Celtic religion having fled Brittany for Ireland after the war. Skorzeny, who left for Franco’s Spain to run anticommunist training camps for a variety of shady international organisations, would joke that the Republic of Ireland was ‘too conservative’ for his tastes.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Congressional Healthcare Bill in America I spent a good deal of this morning and yesterday reading over the proposed American healthcare bill (or at least, a compound version; there appear to be five doing the rounds). I don't want to blog on the details of it immediately. It's also a bill, which may well stall in the Senate or be overtaken by events, and which could yet be critically amended. It is the product of Congress, not the administration per se, and the lawyers have not yet got at it. I had some instant worries about it though. In no particular order, I'll list them; Firstly, it can't allow individuals to choose their doctor and treatment in the long run; instead, it will practically formalise the role of doctors as salaried employees of large medical groups. Sarah Palin is onto something with the idea that this will then allow essentially ideological or non-medical outlooks on, say, euthanasia, abortion, transgender issues, or non-emergency treatments of c...
William Orpen There are four major Christian traditions, which are of course Catholic, Orthodox, Armenian and Coptic. Some sects and cults also exist, like the Moonies or Anglicanism. Yet in some bizarre way this weekend, protestant contributions to something other than the seizure of churches have been making their way into my consciousness. I suppose that the first indication of this trend was a reflection in an old copy of Gibbon that he actually became cultured because of Calvinism. Packed off to Switzerland because he went Catholic at an otherwise boring Oxford, Gibbon fell in love with Suzanne Cuchod, and with Greek because of instruction from a Calvinist mentor. It's an odd thing--I keep coming across indications of Calvinists who could have fun, though they doubtless thought that they would pay for it later, and whose political intelligence was second to none. Althusius springs to mind, for instance. But then what am I thinking, I thought to myself? I've sat on balconi...
Damon Buffini I'm not quite sure what to make of this story. Damon Buffini, a multi-millionaire in the City, and a very accomplished man, seems to have heard staff he regarded as lazy and ungrateful at the upper levels of management complaining about restaurants. He subsequently forced them all to eat two-day old Big Macs whilst reminding them of how lucky they are. It's nice to know that Saturn--in the form of a sort of globalisation guevara--could force his children to eat rather than devouring them, as in Goya's painting. How broken do people have to be not to walk out, though? I guess from his point of view, if they had any spine they'd be in business on their own. The whole thing is horribly fascinating.