Ireland's two twentieth century Patriarchs
Irish politics
and historiography have been (and continue to be) highly patriarchal, in both
the ancient and modern senses. A wealth
exists of striking and memorable stories of women, from Maebh through St Brigid
to the womens’ peace movement in the North and the transformative presidencies
of Mary Robinson and Mary McAleese. Despite this, the remembered figures marking the
way-points of modern Irish history have tended to be men.
This feature has
been reinforced by the way in which the casual and repressed violence of Irish
society has tended to make the understanding and management of male behaviour a
priority of all. It has been a constant of Irish history for millennia. The
earliest tales of the druids and Queens, if somewhat balanced by those of
ancient Irish deities, for instance, would not cover the island in woke glory.
Things are
arguably worse when one turns to the remembered history of the past two hundred
and fifty years. Wolfe Tone, Daniel O’Connell, Charles Stuart Parnell, Michael
Collins, and John Hume, John and Robert Kennedy, and perhaps Tip O’Neill, WB
Yeats, and Oscar Wilde would fit in most people’s list of the greatest Irish
people, but Connie Markiewicz, Lady Gregory, Grace O’Malley, Sinead O’Connor
and Maureen O’Hara would remain somewhat obscure.
There are
sometimes excuses for this in Britain, ‘the island full of people who never
remember’ as opposed to the one ‘full of people who never forget’ in the old
joke. For obvious reasons, for instance, Lady Astor is described to tour groups
in the Palace of Westminster as the ‘first British female member of parliament’
and even has a bas-relief in the wall of the parliamentary post room to
commemorate her existence. Markiewicz goes unmentioned, though given she was a
Sinn Fein member who would have been happy to see the place blown up, that is
perhaps understandable.
Patriarchy
abounds. History is about telling stories. Part of the difficulty is that Irish
stories of the private and intimate sphere—of all the things that matter in
life—tend to revolve around mothers, aunts, sisters, and wives, whereas public
ones have been built for good reasons around men. If women have not broken
through into politics until recently without huge effort or civil derangement,
then the field was one of men. If sexual differences leading to the tragic
destruction of lives based around homosexuality have been important, then the
stories are perforce focussed on men because Irish sporting, drinking,
fighting, and social culture was so homoerotic that it was threatened by openly
gay identities.[1] If
iconic stylised images of women were sustaining and important to women in the
Catholic church, that church was disgraced and disarmed by the activities of
deeply disordered and destructive men. Somehow, a culture and history sustained
and made functional by legions of determined, stoic, and put-upon women was
focussed almost exclusively on men.
Things recur and
revert in such situations to those male characters who become palimpsests of
their communities, figures in their own right upon whom other narratives are
overwritten. It helps if they die young and can bear the weight of fantasies
and speculation on the otherworld might have beens, of course. Michael Collins
and John Kennedy will be eternally remembered in the dying possibilities of
futures lost in sunlit moments, whilst O Connell, Wilde, and Parnell died with
broken hearts at moments of moral spasm which have been immediately and
subsequently regretted. James Joyce, at least, had the sense to leave for
places which were as obscure to the Irish as some wished his humour to be.
Two twentieth
century men, who can be legitimately called patriarchs, defined separate but
very similar sorts of Irishness across very long careers. In an odd and almost
parallel way they lived out attempts to bend or deny the future before finding
redemption at the end, one in a kind of victory and the other in a sort of
defeat. They tend to be judged and assessed separately, partly because of
poisons they helped stir into modern history, but also because their public
images became contrasting archetypes whilst they were still alive. One was
imagined into being the great defender of rural, agricultural, Catholic
Ireland, and the other was the fierce defender of Scots-Irish Protestantism wet
with the waters of the Bann and the Boyne.
In that sense,
Ian Paisley and Eamon De Valera embodied the patriarchy of Irish history in
full, at least for the seventy or so years after 1950. The lessons and
perspectives which can be taken from their lives have made them elemental
figures. They were as capable of being destructive as any elements are. The
memory of them should be handled with caution.
A comparison of the two, however, suggests a good deal about Irish
political life and character.
Of the two,
Paisley was the more consistently destructive, perhaps because the
circumstances in which he existed—which he helped create—meant that he did not
obtain executive power until the end. He grew up in an explicitly sectarian
jurisdiction and rose to prominence as a founder of the ‘Protestant Unionist
Party’ in 1966, which emerged out of the ‘Ulster Protestant Action’ vigilante
movement that he supported vigorously. Paisley’s tastes for vigilante and
paramilitary action are often forgotten today—not least in Colin Bateman and
Nick Hamm’s 2016 The Journey—but they were very real. Ian Paisley, the
founder of a Church and zealot of Christ, was also an agitator and instigator
of armed Protestant patrols in the Ulster Unionist Council, the Ulster Workers’
Council, and the Third Force militia of the early nineteen eighties. He
promoted strikes which targeted Catholics and power sharing, humiliated a
moderate reforming prime minister, associated himself with the inflammation of
the Drumcree protest in 1995, and, despite an apparent conversion to Stormont
self-government (on a majoritarian basis) in 1971, campaigned against every
single attempt to calm the Troubles. At one point he told a crowd that Catholic
houses were burning down because they contained stores of petrol bombs. He also
campaigned against the present settlement right up until the moment in 2007
when he became First Minister of Northern Ireland, his one and only executive
office.
Despite this,
and somewhat bizarrely, Paisley identified himself as an Irishman. In him, the seventeenth
and twentieth century seemed to form a bizarre nexus. The words, phrases, and
concerns of Foxe’s Book of Martyrs slipped perhaps more easily from his
lips than any concerns for civil rights, but this was the language of the
Ulster and American Scots-Irish, and was accompanied by a fierce idiosyncratic
belief that he was supporting Protestant Liberty in speaking so. There are
still Catholic constituents of Ian Paisley’s who will note that, as a
representative, he tried to promote their personal causes or resolve their
difficulties, and there are few stories of private boorishness. Thanks to the
internet, for instance, a strange personal favour done by the ‘Reverend Dr’ for
his chat-show host daughter is preserved online. In it, Paisley appears on a
couch in the early eighties with other guests, telling jokes about his
reputation. One in particular is a self-effacing one which talks of an
encounter with a nun that at least makes a man normally shown as brimful of
shouting negativity laughing at himself.[2]
De Valera, at
least from the perspective of the more middle-class urban areas of Ireland,
committed three major sins during his long career. Firstly, he was defiantly
and very thoroughly Catholic, and rurally-minded which is almost a sin in
modern Ireland. Secondly, he tried to wreck the Anglo-Irish Treaty despite
having encouraged it and might in the process have created the conditions for
Michael Collins’ death. Thirdly, he tends to be blamed for reflecting the
neutrality many Irish embraced during the great moral challenge of modern
European history in 1939-45, a point made by Winston Churchill at the time as
well as many afterwards. This ‘image problem’ grew after 1945, when Ireland
became an unfortunate haven for a number of prominent former National
Socialists.[3]
Nevertheless, De
Valera was also the man who structurally, if not nominally, created the modern
republic in 1937, when he took advantage of the Abdication crisis to remove the
Crown from the government of twenty-six Irish counties. He did not declare a
new republic, however; that was left to John Costello, perhaps the most
underrated of the Taoisigh, in 1948. ‘Dev’ chaired the Assembly of the League
of Nations, created a new and successful Republican party in Fianna Fail, acted
as President of the Executive, Taoiseach, and Leader of the Opposition during
various long stints between 1932 and 1959, and began and ended his career as a
President, in 1919-22 and again in 1959-73.
Both Paisley and
De Valera rejected treaties in ways which set the course of politics for
decades afterward. ‘Dev’s 1920 rejection
of the Anglo-Irish treaty, divided Sinn Fein ultimately into Fianna Fail, Fine
Gael, and a violent splinter group and petrifying Irish politics. ‘Papa Doc
Paisley’ was probably the single most important individual involved in the
rejection of the Sunningdale Agreements in 1973, though attempts to repeat the
trick failed in 1986 and 1998. Both men were essentially parochial but diligent
members of international bodies, the League of Nations for De Valera and the
European Parliament for Paisley. Both took theology seriously but had enough
moral flexibility to only privately regret the murderous consequences of doing
so, for allies and others. As executives and representatives, neither was marked
personally by bigotry, and yet in public statements and appeals, they could be
shockingly and deliberately sectarian. Both were theatrical, but with happy
marriages and personal lives, and both, probably, would have been happier in
other academic or ecclesiastical environments. Paisley, for instance, founded
his Free Presbyterian Church and De Valera his Dublin Institute of Advanced
Studies.
De Valera and
Paisley largely held uncomplicated religious beliefs in the conservative
traditions of their separate faiths. Their relationship to spirituality was
however complex. Paisley founded his church with others in opposition to the
perceived liberalism and lack of democratic rigour of its predecessor (the
Church allowed dancing and parties and was accused of rigging elections) and
built relationships with Bob Jones University and congregations across the
English Speaking world, sustaining some eighty ecclesial communities by 2022.
Yet Paisley also
stood down as Moderator in the face of criticism in 2007 that he had become
‘liberal’ by leading a government which protected homosexual rights. This did
represent a sort of evolution. In 1977, for instance, Paisley had, in between
other things, led a ‘Save Ulster from Sodomy’ campaign protesting against the
decriminalisation of the practice.[4]
Subsequently, Paisley returned to a focus on other issues. De Valera, a
lifelong conservative catholic, refused to allow Irish front organisations to
aid Franco, stopped short of making Catholicism a state religion, paid lip
service to secular appointments in a democracy, and promoted physics,
astrophysics, and Ireland’s pagan heritage over Catholic scholarship at the
IAS.
Both De Valera
and Paisley produced faithful political heirs for one generation, although
neither managed to create a personal movement. Charles de Gaulle may have
allowed De Valera to use the ‘toi’ form (Dev was the only leader in Europe to
whom de Gaulle would speak English out of respect after Churchill) but the
story of ‘DeValerists’ is essentially one of a rapidly diminished tradition of
political criminals, dissemblers, and grafters of whom Charles Haughey is
probably the prime example. If De Valera had ever entertained an idea of Irish
Gaullism, the entry of the country enthusiastically into the European Community
in 1973 (under his chief heir) scotched the programme much more efficiently
than De Gaulle’s Luxembourg compromise did for France.
By the same
token, Ian Paisley came to Ulster unionism at a time of profound fragmentation
in the already limited constellation of Ulster Protestantism and left what
remained circling a black hole. Of the two, Paisley was the more
unapologetically sectarian, rising through the vehicles of the Protestant
unionist party—a name that offered no doubts to any—and then the Democratic
Unionist Party, before embracing the somewhat unlikely role of first minister
on the collapse of the Ulster establishment. Paisley benefitted from something
which De Valera cut off, which was the ability to blame the British for
unpopular moves that his tradition forced them into making, and did not have to
cope with, for instance, the need to create an healthcare system or manage his
state through a world war.
Both De Valera
and Paisley do seem, however, to have been untouched by the grotesque and still
unclear abuse scandals which they must have had an intimation of in the Church
and at Kincora. Like John Paul II, amongst other charismatic leaders, they seem
both to have had the capacity to ignore deeply troubling eruptions of
elaborated badness which could have destroyed their projects. In the research
for this essay, I could find no trace that Ian Paisley ever made use of the
widely-rumoured homosexuality of a rival Unionist leader, nor that, after 1977,
he actively persecuted any gay people. By contrast, De Valera’s Ireland
maintained the 1885 British ban after the North abandoned its commitment to the
law, and neither Taoiseach De Valera nor the Presidential version every tried
in any way to challenge it.[5]
The comparison
of Ireland’s two modern patriarchs eventually folds. Flexible as Paisley
eventually became, even to the point of working closely with Martin McGuinness,
he served just over one year as First Minister after the Good Friday
agreements, between May 2007 and June 2008. From 1949 to 2007, he was a
presence in political campaigns and legislatures, but usually in the form of an
anabaptist anarchy. Set against Paisley’s fifty-seven-year career of wrecking,
De Valera’s six decades were vastly more constructive.
De Valera was
also much clearer, as perhaps befits the mathematician he was and could have
continued to be, about what he wanted and needed to do in his career, whereas,
oddly, the career of Ian Paisley illustrates some of the confusing contrasts of
Scots-Irishry. English political culture, it has been observed, is divided
between Blake and Bentham, romance and facts. No similar line has been applied
to Ireland, but if one did so, Paisley would make an interesting Blake or
Coleridge to De Valera’s far less Romantic Statist.
[1]
The North legalised male homosexuality in 1982, for instance, whereas the
Republic only did so in 1993. Given that the northern liberalisation was
imposed by the British, no arguments can be made for any sort of Ulster
progressivism.
[2] In
fact, most clips of Paisley devolve into him as an old man decrying
sectarianism in housing whilst refusing to ever acknowledge explicitly that he
had ever been wrong about anything, shouting as a young and middle aged man at
crowds, or laughing and smiling in debate or on campaign.
[3]
Ironically, a good deal of this sort of thing started under Fine Gael.
Skorzeny, Hitler’s favourite commando and a post-war anti-Communist agitator, was
more comfortable in Fascist Spain than Ireland, and left more or less for good
after the De Valera government refused him residency in 1963. Apocryphal
stories tell of Skorzeny claiming that his departure was prompted by the appeal
of better weather in a less conservative country. According to Maurice Walsh,
writing in The Dublin Review in 2007, there were ‘substantial’ numbers
of Irish people in the British Union of Fascists before the second World War,
and Oswald Mosley, its leader, lived comfortably in Ireland after 1951. Mosley
viewed Ireland’s ideal relationship to Britain as being ‘England’s pre-1959 Cuba,’
meaning that it should enjoy autonomy unless London decided that it should not.
[4] The
campaign attracted 70,000 supporters but failed in the face of the European
Court of Human Rights and the Government of the United Kingdom. In 1981, a case
originating in Belfast in 1975, Dudgeon v the UK (App No 7525/76, [1981] ECHR 5, (1982) 4 EHRR 149, IHRL 31
(ECHR 1981) declared the continued ban on male homosexual acts in the North
incompatible with human rights. The British government then legislated in 1982.
[5] In
contrast, for instance, with the future President Mary Robinson, and the future
Presidential candidate David Norris.
Comments