One tendency amongst students is to be verbose. This concentration on wordiness is sometimes encouraged by academic reading and tuition. Often, those who write on keyboards are not used to assessing how long their sentences are. When people write in this fashion, points are lost and readers become unsure of what they are reading.
Exactly the same
cognitive point applies to readers. Few people are trained these days, either
by themselves or others, to concentrate a passage into its key points.
I would like to show
you how to analyse and condense a passage by using what might seem an
intimidating extract from Blaise Pascal. The full quote is below.
The normal rules which I have suggested to you
for ‘gobbits’—history extracts that involve asking ‘who, what, where, when,
how, to whom, and why?’—do not apply here. Instead, let’s have a look at the words,
paragraph by paragraph.
“Your
desired destination is faith, but you do not know the road. You want to cure
yourself of unbelief, and you ask for remedies; learn from those who were
hampered like you and who now wager all they possess. These are people who know
the road you would like to follow; they are cured of the malady for which you
seek a cure, so follow them and begin as they did - by acting as if they
believed. In the natural course of events this in itself will make you believe,
this will train you”
What is Pascal saying here? Be ruthless.
1)
You want faith.
2)
You want to learn from those who have it because you
don’t know how to get it.
3)
By copying them, you think that that you will be
trained and improved.
‘Boiling down’ again (it is always a good idea to see if you
can get the idea in a line);
You see copying the behaviours of
the faithful as a way to get it and to improve yourself.
Second paragraph:
“This
will train you”: Pascal’s original verb is abetir, literally to “make like the
beasts”, and this has made it seem to some critics as if Pascal is offering us
a degrading prescription for the crushing of critical rationality. The
underlying idea is in fact much more subtle: the ancient notion ( going back to
Aristotle ) of the training or habituation of the emotions as part of the path
towards a desired goal. We become virtuous adults, says Aristotle, by being
trained as children to be virtuous, so that, for example, it eventually becomes
natural and automatic for us to feel the right emotions (e.g. courageous or
generous emotions ) in the appropriate circumstances. You guide young children
on the path to the desired destination not, initially, by reasoning with them,
since they are not in a position to make the relevant rational evaluations, but
by training them, moulding their emotions and conduct until the requisite
behaviour becomes second nature
1. Training
is what people do with animals and this might seem beneath your dignity because
it does not involve thinking.
2. People
have been doing this for a long time, however.
3. We
train children to be good adults, for example.
4. Training
works, often because children aren’t capable of the appropriate level of
rationality for anything else.
Third
paragraph:
The
fact that emotions are trained, perhaps rather as a singer might train his
voice or a tennis player her modes of responding to a serve does not, however,
mean an abandonment of critical rationality, since it remains true that the
goal of the training is rationally defensible - and indeed beneficial for all
concerned. Pascal’s position is that there is a rational (indeed almost
utilitarian) argument for religious belief, hinging on the benefits of the
religious life.
1.
Training emotions has analogies on physical training
for adults too.
2.
It does not mean abandoning reason.
3.
It is rational to want the benefits of religious
training.
Fourth
paragraph:
The
benefits Pascal actually concentrates on are next-worldly: he develops the
famous wager or bet, namely that the sacrifices involved in living a religious
life re well worth the chance, however remote, of an infinite reward in the
next life. What looks like a crudely self interested calculation has seemed to
many readers harshly out of tune with the very idea of spiritual salvation; but
fortunately we d not have to go into the ethics of the wager here, since the
benefits of the spiritual life that we have been focusing on are not motivating
carrots added on as a later reward, but are instead manifest goods
intrinsically linked to the value of the spiritual life as actually lived by
its adherents: the care of the soul, tranquillity of mind, release from the
false pursuit of egotism and material gain, a closer awareness of the mystery
of life, an affirmation of its profundity and its blessings.
1.
Pascal is mostly concerned with an afterlife.
2.
We don’t have to be.
3.
The benefits of a religious outlook are things that we
can use and enjoy here and now.
Unlike Pascal, we can enjoy the benefits of religious
training here and now.
So that
original big, potentially intimidating piece, now says:
You see
copying the behaviours of the faithful as a way to get it and to improve
yourself. Training is a legitimate way to incorporate values, with a long
background in history and everyday life, and is part of becoming a good adult.
Rational people can gain benefits from copying religious discipline just as
they can discipline their talents and develop their skills. Unlike Pascal, we
can enjoy the benefits of religious training here and now.
Which is
another way of saying
If you
copy the behaviour of people you admire, the benefits of their life can be
yours even if the training isn’t really about thinking.
Comments