Some undergraduates have in the past benefitted from advice about papers. Here is some about papers which are focussed on the historical meaning or importance of architecture. It relates to paper writing in general.
There
are several ways of including a location or building in a paper. One should
first of all define clearly whether one wishes to adopt a narrow or a broad
view; are you looking at a place for itself—its aesthetics, structure, or impression
to you—are are you going to connect the place, your impression of it, or its
history to some greater thing?
So—crudely,
set up a tickbox.
Am
I talking about architecture or the way architecture reflects and builds
society?
Am
I talking about a place or building or collection of buildings or is my primary
focus the history of something greater?
It
may help to focus upon an activity or person connected with the place. So, for
instance, fleet street seems apt to connect to newspapers or to the way in
which the British media and law function as networks of personal information
and influence defined by physical proximity. Buckingham Palace might symbolise
mid-victorian ideas of modest majesty, public control of the monarch, or a new
centrality for a symbolic monarchy in contrast to republican forms in the
nineteenth century imperial mind. Downing street might be the setting for a
note on how the executive in Britain physically works. Alternatively, the
actual buildings of fleet street might speak to something fundamental—old
fashioned values, alcoholism, gossip or the failure of the country to modernise
in the twentieth century? One could thereby connect to a wider social point. A
particular incident in history, or for that matter a non-instant, like the
career of the (apparently fictional) Sweeney todd, may form the basis for a
note on how historical and legal memory work and one may then move on to
connect them to an interpretation of a political system, such as the common
law, for instance, over the model of Republican justice in France, for
instance.
One
of course could skirt the boundaries of psuedo-intellectualism and pretension
in such efforts, but remember, papers are somewhat confusing in part because
they are subject to several different historical forms and influences.
For
instance, papers began as a way of trying to test students which evolved out of
the essay form. They are somewhat subjective, in that the student is expected
to follow from the advice of the tutor, and in some subjects to follow the
methods of the master, so as to achieve a mimicry and thereby perpetuate what
is known. But originality and insight are also rewarded, which may mean
departure from or argument with the methods and ideas to which one has been exposed.
The contradictions inherent in this testing process have led to papers largely
being replaced or supplemented with multiple-choice questions and supported,
data-response answers in many subjects and countries, particularly since a
paper is often open to the criticism of subjective and conventionally-driven
marking. The paper is also now used within the context of a class or lecture
group, whereas of course as a testing device it achieves its best results over
a small seminar on tutorial. It is a test of research methods and argument too,
but critically therefore depends upon the resources available to a person and
to the fairness of (and control exerted over) an examiner.
Essays
arose slightly earlier in time than papers and in fact have a different genesis
in the self-discipline to which intellectuals of the period surrounding
humanism and the reformation in Europe aspired, and are classically dated to
Montaigne. Essays were thus expected literally to be ‘efforts’ in which a
particular proposition or moral lesson was posited, explained, evaluated and
applied in a structured fashion. Self-expression was not the point; self
discipline was. The essay, rather than translation of latin, greek or Hebrew
(let alone archaic languages) thus became the primary form in the humanities.
Social scientists after the enlightenment gradually changed this focus to one
in which essays became psuedo-scientific ‘papers’ that sought to base arguments
upon real world data, tests and applications and to derive lessons from them.
This further complicated the word ‘essay’ of course, and led to some further
confusion amongst students. When academic texts adopted as standard the
professional forms of written theses, with their conventions explained in The
Oxford Handbook of Style in the eastern hemisphere and the Chicago manual of
style in the west, things were made even richer; not necessarily a help to
students but only a hindrance if ‘papers’ are just seen as a chance to write a
literate letter to a tutor rather than a form in which one person can demonstrate
their rationality and their argument to an unknown but reasonable observer
familiar with their terms.
So
it is not an easy thing to write a paper. Here are some suggestions about what
should be in them;
- An introduction should define terms
and set out what one wishes to talk about and, critically, what the terms
mean. This allows one to grasp control of arguments, to direct the reader,
and to avoid redefining over and over in the middle of things.
- A discussion should then move on from
definitions to note how an argument can be applied, how a thing
works, what effects, inferences, structural twists or insights emerge from
the definition and so on. The discussion should further the point made
too.
- An essay should contain examples,
counter-examples, analogies or practical demonstrations of that which is
being discussed. This brings home to the reader the focus of argument and
helps strengthen the parameters within which the reader can apply
themselves.
- Essays and papers should contain
elements of evaluation. At the very crudest level this means that one
should be able to say what was good, what was bad, and what can be learned
from a thing, and what worth the thing was. This latter point is apt to
seem trite; everything potentially has worth to the conscious and
enquiring mind as a basis for its own application and discipline, but not
everything has the same worth in a sane world or in a general context. An
essay should tease out the distinctions; it is therefore a form in which
moral or practical hierarchy is somewhat evident
- An essay and a paper should be clearly
written and should use clear, simple terms. It sometimes helps to
construct a flowchart of what should be in it and to set out the broad
outlines of an argument before one begins. Ideally, one would then write,
set the writing aside (if one has that luxury) and, a couple of days
later, one would check the writing against the original aim and for errors
or confusion. Not everyone has that luxury of course. So ensure that anything
you write can be summarised quickly and easily in a sentence or two—that
you can ‘state your case’. Generally you will be able to, just as you will
be able to narrate the bare bones of a story if it is any good. Have a
firm conclusion.
Occasionally
people turn up in the world of literature or the humanities generally who will
tell you that ‘writing is about self-expression’, ‘’no one has ownership of a
fact’, ‘structure is a matter of social control’ and that ‘having a beginning,
middle and end’ is not really important. To my mind they are generally wrong.
There is a certain pleasure in very fine writing for the sake of it but such
indulgence without a point largely leads to mental or spiritual obesity or
worse and doesn’t get anyone anywhere.
There
are some practical points upon which I wanted to touch. I like footnotes. They
are easy to see and they do not substantially impede the flow of an argument.
They should come at the end of a line, not immediately after the term to which
they refer, and they should not repeat at length; so a shorter term, or
‘op.cit’, or ‘ibid’ where appropriate are good. They make the reader’s life
easier. Some people, and some word processing programmes, seem to prefer
endnotes. I will never mark anyone down for that. The purpose of a note of any
sort is to show that that which was being asserted can be, if not wholly
justified, then sourced, and that one has not made it up. Long footnotes that
are in fact collateral asides are entertaining but many professors do not like
them. Footnotes that repeat or explain points which could be made better in the
text or which are essential to an argument should be made in a text.
Comments