Radical Nationalism, the Great War, and Irish Independence
Sinn
Fein (translated as ‘ourselves’) is the name of a variety of parties in Irish
nationalist history which share a common tradition on the radical and violent
side of Irish republicanism. The traditions which inform its existence include
those of political terrorism and conspiracy and reach back through the Irish
Republican Brotherhood, the Invincibles, the Fenians, and Young Ireland, as
well as that of the rising of 1798. At the same time, the modern party
describes itself as a democratic, socialist, and republican party and is the
second party in the present northern Irish assembly.
The Sinn Fein tradition is notoriously fissile,
emerging from different groups, giving rise to the modern Fianna Fail and Fine
Gael in the Republic, and splitting to give rise the Worker’s Party in the
north of Ireland in the 1970, and thence to the Democratic Left and Irish
Republican Socialist Party.
‘SF’
has been a substantial recipient of Irish American money and support, despite being
at various times Maoist rather than Catholic, and has an antagonistic
relationship with the current Republic, which some of its members refer to
dismissively as ‘the Free State’ or ‘the twenty-six counties.’ Despite this, the
party runs both in the Republic and the north, and views itself as an all-Irish
institution.
Sinn
Fein in its various iterations has been closely associated with the various
versions of the Irish Republican Army, though it is a custom in the party and appears
to be a condition of the oath tradition that members do not acknowledge a
direct personal association.[1]
Origins
The
origins of Sinn Fein belie its later position on the radical left.[2] It
emerged in 1905 from three groups; the Gaelic Society created by Arthur Griffith
from his United Irishman newspaper, the radical womens’ group Daughters
of Ireland, and intellectual members of the Gaelic League.[3]
Griffith himself was something of an odd fish, enthused equally by the example
of Hungarian national resurrection in the Dual Monarchy after 1867, and by the
idea of organising for elections and then abstaining from taking seats at
Westminster in order to force the creation of an Irish legislature.[4]
Since Griffith was not a republican, another group, modelling itself on the
Dungannon convention of 1798 and the Jacobin clubs of the French Revolution
known as the Dungannon Clubs, also organised in the 1900s and spread across
Ireland, considering itself another part of the Sinn Fein family.
Sinn
Fein therefore looks like a confusion of movements, or what the French might term
a congeries. In fact, after a century of anticolonial nationalism, it
can be said to have blazed something of a trail. The African National Congress
and the Indian Congress movement are of course different organisations, with
different histories, but they functioned for a good part of their existence as
umbrella groups for multiple organisations, as did nationalist groups in other
parts of Africa and Asia within the British Empire [5]
Sinn
Fein’s disparate origins are somewhat hidden officially by a kink in the
organisation’s timeline, occasioned by pressure from the USA. There, prominent nationalists
such as John Devoy were keen to offer money and help to a single Irish
nationalist party distinct from the IPP and focussed on Gaelic identity and
independence. They would not do so for what they considered a collection of divided
groups, however, and so in 1907, after tortuous negotiations, the Gaelic
Society, the National Council movement, and the Dungannon clubs all merged.
They backdated their merger to 1905 so as to use the party name ‘Sinn Fein.’
The
rise of Sinn Fein was aided by the distraction of the Liberal Government, which
still maintained a large majority, and the drift on the IPP. Like many new
parties in the UK then and after, however, it experienced initial partial
success, gaining between a quarter and a third of the vote, but failed to come
first in enough places to solidify its existence. In truth, it was in danger of
becoming an answer in future trivia questions rather than establishing a new
state or recreating Gaeldom, as Griffith, Maud Gonne, and others had hoped it
would on its foundation.
Sinn
Fein nevertheless had two things wanting in the Redmondite Irish Parliamentary
Party. Firstly, there was a trickle of American money to keep it in the game.
Secondly, and possibly more importantly, the party was clearly associated with
the Irish Volunteers and the tradition of semi-secret Irish republicanism in
the Atlantic world after its merger with the Dungannon clubs. It was also
organised enough to become resilient to electoral failures, and therefore able
to record them as growing indications of a rising tide which could overcome
setbacks and recessions. In politics, one needs an organisation and a
narrative to succeed.
The
Great War destroyed British rule in most of Ireland. For many years,
nationalists in Ireland and loyalist nationalists in Ulster found it convenient
to present a narrative in which Ulster bore huge losses in the wasteful battles
of the initial phases of the war, whilst the South became increasingly restive
and then rebellious. In fact, this was not true. All Irish losses in the war
were terrible. 49.000 soldiers from Ireland perished in the war, out of over 200,000
who served.[6]
Of those who served, 5000 of the deaths came from the service of the Ulster
division at the Battle of the Somme. It suited later politicians to claim that the
bulk of Ireland’s losses overall were of Ulstermen, but this is simply incorrect.
It
is also incorrect that Sinn Fein had in itself anything to do with the Easter
Rising of 1916, which horrified the Unionist community and British public
opinion. In fact, the rising went unnoticed for some days, and most Irish
people had little to do with it; in this Sinn Fein was representative.
It
was the British and media overreaction, the failure to implement Home Rule
despite the assurances of the IPP, and the Conscription Crisis of 1918 that
broke Irish constitutionalism and the Irish war effort. [7]
The execution of some of the principal leaders of the rising at Kilmainham, who
immediately became martyrs was counterproductive, and led to Asquith suspending
the judicial shootings in case Irish-American opinion swayed President Wilson
against joining the War. It is also fair to say that British public opinion was
not taken with the killings.[8]
A
period of back-and-forth, as often happens when one party replaces another,
took place in 1917-18 between the IPP, which won three by-elections to Sinn
Fein’s six, as members of the Easter Rising were gradually released from prison
by Lloyd George in a further attempt to curry favour with American opinion.
This was a remarkable turnaround for a party which had been almost broke in 1915.
When SF stayed out of talks about the implementation of Home Rule, the ‘Irish
Convention’ of 2017, the party was judged by some observers to have edged ahead
of the IPP, which joined and ended feeing betrayed.
Conscription
was what finally did the IPP in. The Ludendorff offensive of Spring 1918 almost
worked, and had it not been for the entry of young American soldiers into the
war, probably would have defeated the near-exhausted allies by summer, although
the plan was to win before the Americans could arrive. The British lacked
domestic or colonial troops to cope with the initial attack, and so sought a draft
(which is what conscription is.) Conscription was by now normal in Great Britain,
but had never been extended to Ireland. Lloyd-George proposed to do so.
This
was a disastrous and stupid decision. It united the Irish Parliamentary Party, Sinn
Fein, the Roman Catholic Church, and Irish trade unions and socialists against
Ulster and London. A clumsy attempt to link draft resisters to a ‘German plot’
on the lines of a real earlier one involving the nationalist hero Sir Roger
Casement (executed for treason in England in 1916) made matters worse, and a
further attempt to encourage the Irish to join the French army voluntarily
misfired. After the expenditure of Britain’s low remaining reserves of
political capital on the island of Ireland, the UK gave up on conscription,
which was no longer needed since the USA had joined the war.
The
ongoing effect, however, had been to radicalize Irish nationalism. Key members
of Sinn Fein, which now led the national cause, now initiated plans to murder
the British cabinet (which were cancelled) and to achieve the independence of
Ireland by any means necessary. For the rising and the appearance of indifference,
both the British and French were determined to keep Irish representatives away
from the peace conference planned for the end of the war. In the meantime, in
the 1918 election, Sinn Fein won a sweeping majority of Irish seats and
promptly refused to sit in Westminster, sitting as an Irish Assembly, the Dail
Eireann from January 1919. Three
weeks later, the Irish War of Independence began.
[1] There are currently
several ‘dissident’ republican groups using the title of IRA, including the ‘Real
IRA’ and the ‘Continuity IRA.’ The Provisional IRA, which was active during the
‘Troubles’ of 1969-1997, declared a ceasefire and agreed to put its arms beyond
use under the supervision of an international commission after 1997 as part of
the ‘Good Friday’ agreements and ongoing peace process.
[2] Apart from a few obvious
occasions, I have used English names for organisations which were self-identified
by Irish language terms, for the convenience of readers. I mean no offence to
any Gaelic readers or enthusiasts.
[3] The name Sinn Fein was
in fact suggested to Arthur Griffith by Mary Ellen Butler, a Gaelic enthusiast
and cousin of Edward Carson who led the Ulster Unionist effort to prevent Home
Rule and establish a state in northern Ireland.
[4] A policy still
followed by Sinn Fein.
[5] There were multiple
cross-fertilising links, both inspirationally and in the form of individual politicians
and thinkers, between the Indian national movement which emerged in the 1880s
and the Irish Home Rule and independence cause. See for instance R.V.Brasted, “Irish
Models and the Indian National Congress 1870-1922” in South Asia: Journal of
South Asian Studies Vol 8:1 1985 pp24-45. Also, Arpita Sen, “Belonging to
One Nation: the role of two Irish women in fostering nationalist consciousness
in India” Proceedings of the Indian History Congress vol 78 (2017)
pp797-804.
[6] Some 100,000 other
Irish served with Canadian, Australian, American, or French armies. The
majority of all Irish solders who served (57%) reflected the religious balance
on the island in that they were Catholics.
[7] An Irish nationalist
song, ‘The Man from the Daily Mail’ satirises the tendency of the British gutter
press, represented by the Mail, to nominate everything in Ireland as
Sinn Fein except the actual Sinn Fein in order to sell the sensational threat
of an Irish uprising to their readers.
[8] Yeats is the most
prominent to have limned the leaders who were killed ‘bewildered with excess of
love’ but the story of Joseph Plunkett married to his love Grace on the morning
of his execution, has proven equally attractive over the years, as has that of
James Connolly, the socialist firebrand and ‘Irish rebel’ who returned to
Catholicism before his execution.
Comments