Skip to main content
A Bill of Attainder, and worse things

The Constitution of the United States, and those of many of the several states, bans Bills of Attainder. These are specific legislative acts directed at a particular individual that deprive them of life, liberty, or property. The Founders of the Constitutions evidently thought that equality before the law and the absence of retrospective civil punishment were important to the rule of law.

This country is on the edge of abandoning that insight, and passing a bill of attainder against a failed banker. This is how law dies.

Fred Goodwin, not to harp on the point, was the first in his family to go to University. His dad was an engineer. He didn't go to a fee-paying school. He didn't go to Oxford or Cambridge. His corporate raids were encouraged by the pseudo-Darwinian orthodoxy of the banking industry, and hurt only bankers, who lived by that coin. The English corporate classes clearly loathe him. He made it, by legal means, to a high position in his society.

Now, the public-school educated ideologist who sits as Deputy leader of the Labour Party--a great grand-niece of Joseph Chamberlain, daughter of a Harley Street Physician, Legal officer of the National Council for Civil Liberties when the Paedophile Information Exchange was affiliated to it--wants to overturn the rule of law and take away Mr Goodwin's pension. When she failed as a minister, and was sacked, she joined the back benches and, as far as I can tell, joined others in voting to increase her own pension. In office, she promoted exactly the same mechanism as allowed Fred Goodwin's board to assess his pension--a committee on which he did not sit--to consider the remuneration of MPs.

Now she hints at a Bill of Attainder.

In this, she is supported by a former colleague who presided over the disbursement of billions in public money to the Railtrack company, until it was bankupted, and who once punched a voter; a Chancellor of the Exchequer who began life as a raging political extremist who went to an exclusive school and once threatened in office to break the law, and who then rose to a position where he could be paid parliamentary expenses for sharing the flat of a colleague that apparently was sold by the Prime Minister; and Labour MPs who supported the 'prawn cocktail offensive' by which New Labour encouraged what now appears to be the malefaction of great wealth.

She is also, apparently being supported by the wealthy son of fabric designers who sits as shadow chancellor.

The government of which Ms Harman is a member was elected by 21.59% of the electorate.

The solicitors and barristers who rush to defend multiple murderers and terrorists are nowhere to be seen on the airwaves.

The self-appointed defenders of liberty in this country's press are conjoined with the mob, the children of whom are being out-studied, out-classed and out-employed by hard working, god fearing and education-loving immigrants and their children, or those whose parents pay for their education. They have been abandoned. For this lack of proper educational values, and other subsidiary reasons, they are therefore about to turn on them ; the BNP is registering at four per cent in polls, and presumably only residual shame is keeping more from admitting that they are toying with them.

Mr Goodwin is being fed to the wolves. Before he does anything further, perhaps he can tell us what he knows about allegations of global RBS involvement in the financing of uranium weapons? Or the contingencies involved in the liquidation of the Bank of Credit and Commerce International, which I understand he carried out? Did he know how involved they were with the Medellin cartel and Saddam, and did the British government of the time? Did he inform them when he was doing his job? What British ministerial involvement there was in the Sakhalin II gas and oil project, if any?

The Goodwin affair is a little thing. But it's revealing. This country is on the edge of abandoning the rule of law, at a time when most people are lying to themselves about just how bad this recession is, and how bad it is going to get. Millions are about to lose their jobs, their homes, or the world they thought they lived in.

Look after your family, settle your affairs, pay down your debts and retrench. If you can leave, go. I suspect that, without winning the lottery, you are in exactly the same boat as me, and that you cannot. There are things we could do; no one shows the slightest inclination of doing them.

So, well, we're off for a ride.

Comments

Anonymous said…
Hi Martin,
I'm back to posting as anonymous due to the computer which was supposed to remember my password expecting me to come up with it. I've tried a dozen permutations with no luck so I'll have to think of a new name and write the password down.

Anyway I do feel compelled to respond to your comments. I cannot feel any sympathy whatsoever for FG.It is a complete irrelevance that he was the first in the family to go to university or that his background was not as privileged as those who pursue him now.The man is so greedy and so lacking in remorse that he makes me shudder. (and I know that we've all been invited to join in with the blood lust but it doesn't mean that the anger is not justified.) He is not the only person whose pension should be subject to review and any change in the law should be widely used to punish as many offenders as possible.Also I would like to see MP's of every persuasion made accountable for their grubby self-enrichment.I have to say that Tony Blair, who I once admired enormously, truly gets away with murder. Is he not the recipient of millions from an investment bank? John Prescott is a laugh and he thumped a voter who threw an egg at him. I loved him for that.

I know that the UK is in an awful mess and that this whole affair is a distraction from the main event. If FG is a scapegoat then so be it.If ordinary people (the mob) get some satisfaction from his comeuppance so be it.

No-one knows how bad this situation is going to get and I do think there is an element of hysteria in what the doom-sayers are putting about.This is not a war, nobody is going to die. This recession/depression will run it's course and there will still be some good people left in the country. You will survive.

Mary
Martin Meenagh said…
Hi Mary. First of all, thanks as usual for the comment--and good luck with your password. It's very frustrating forgetting them, and I know exactly what you mean.

I think the first thing to point out is that I'm sometimes driven to sympathise with people because of their opponents. It was a mistake, in my own tiny world, I made most with the Iraq war, as I've written elsewhere on the blog. In part, I supported it because the usual suspects were against it, which wasn't sensible.

Here, though, seeing Goodwin being eaten by the less successful but privileged because he did better than them (and he knew the score and chose an awful industry and waste of life to make money, though the latter's not wrong) is appalling. I can't stand those people. Useless, spineless, smug and righteous in a self-serving way. Perhaps I let a base contempt get the better of me. It's not something to be proud of. The mob is not always wrong, either. It's just that its, well, the mob.

As for changing the law on pensions because of greed, well, I can't agree. He made provisions for himself that were legal. The system was awash with dirty or unjustifiable money. The government and society that knew this revelled in it. Goodwin saw more of the underbelly of what keeps the west rich, and why its better than elsewhere, than you and I have done, at BCCI and in all those projects I alluded to that RBS funded. A man with more of a grasp on the only worthwhile insight in the world--that the only thing that makes anything worthwhile is love, which comes from God--might have been able to walk away but you can't demand a man be a saint.

As for not knowing what this depression is going to lead to, I take your point. I take your point about hysteria. Sometimes, I think I should hold back when writing, on what is a public but an obscure blog, about what seems obvious to me in case people think that. Then I realise that I don't care what people think, and carry on. Truth should be the currency of Reason.

I was being called hysterical when no one saw a recession coming at all. I was also called hysterical last year when I pointed out that none of these grossly inflated 'rescue packages' would work. I'm not suggesting for a minute you're doing that-- I trust your bona fides completely--but think. Telling the truth when things are this bad is not hysteria.

We've had an orgy of gambling--tens of trillions locked up in derivatives markets when there aren't so many dollars in the world. We've had debt wrapping its sun-king way around no end of ordinary lives. We have countries bankrupting themselves and monetary systems that are unsustainable on the back of nonsense about how east asia is going to save everyone. And no one seems to get the point about oil and gas and the global war that is already raging, if you happen to be one of the millions caught up in it.

And lives are run by moral idiots desperate to impose a sort of zombie-capitalist Arminian identity wrapped up in torn-out pages from Voltaire on us.

So it's not doomerism to keep going on about this, though I sometimes do get gloomy about how deliberately stupid people are being--but maybe that is what will get some through. Maybe thats how a lot of people get through life.

People will die, they are dying. Suicides, violence and economic riots are already claiming the lives of people worldwide. I wish in that I was wrong.

As for me, I'll survive on the Trotsky civil war basis--dodging separate armies of women, creditors, taxmen and clients until one of them has the sense to grab an icepick. Since, however, they'll be using it to get around in the face of global cooling when the warming lie fails, I should have a few years left in me yet!

I hope that your foot is better. Watch out for the casserole pans. They're a menace!

You've got to smile, haven't you? :)
berenike said…
Mary - this clip is 3'11' long. Do watch it.

Harman is proposing an illegal act of government violence against someone who has done nothing illegal.
Martin Meenagh said…
Hi Berenike, thanks for your comment too. It's given me an excuse to put the video clip up again, which I love doing!
Anonymous said…
Thank you Martin and Berenike,
I have watched the clip and I take your point. However although I'm not advocating changing the law on the hoof, so to speak ,I would suggest that the law be reformed when individuals can make an ass of it.We need a fairer society. Just because an individual has not broken the law does not mean that we should have no redress.Immoral behaviour should be challenged and the law must evolve.Sometimes the mob is right and if we ignore that then we will have a riot on our hands.

Do beware exploding pyrex dishes. I'm still limping,
Best wishes, Mary.
Martin Meenagh said…
What would be moral behaviour in banking? Which of their core behaviours could be made moral?

I'm not being facetious. The American founders thought that ambition was the ruling passion of the noblest mind. The best would be deeply flawed, and human beings in general could be trusted to be bad rather than good.

So, instead of legislating to make people good, they tried to construct a political order in which badness was trammelled, balanced, checked and directed.

It didn't work--a lot. Slavery, the death of native America, corruption and violence were endemic in American society. Occasionally something different broke through. There was a possibility of minimal, clear law, and a sphere of socially regulated freedom and plurality beneath it.

You've made me think, Mary. I don't think law depends on allowing people to fully express their natures or to be completely free. But I like liberty, and don't want to give myself over completely to Hobbesian gloom. So I wonder, in the civic space, if freedom has to come with limits if it isn't to be completely insane.

Those limits in banking would involve a German- or East-asian style of slow, deliberate and limited lending. That means a fall in effective standards of living.

They would almost certainly impose restraints, and would require a certain public hypocrisy; would that be better than the private hypocrisy of thinking that lives built on credit are marked by real wealth or security?

For ambitious, driven young men as Fred Goodwin once was, and as I once was, limits would probably be the sort of thing that sent one up the wall and down again. Any soiety would suffer consequences of constraint like that, either in emigration, displaced ritual violence, alcoholism, or frustration.

Would they be better than the tremendous freedom business offered, for a few, in Britian and America? What would a doctrine of limits mean for politics?

Hate is a sin against the Holy Spirit, and despising things almost always diminishes an individual, I've learned. Anger is wasteful. But the word for what the modern political class is 'despicable'. Are they preferable to any alternative?

The law is also riven, or marbled, with awful behaviour, and elevating both over businessmen who've been successful according to other criteria is something I wonder about.

Laws almost always have unintended consequences. I think that we have too many. What we need is a decent civic society, or at least one with socially enforced rules that are clear.

To get to that, however, would involve a loss of freedom which I think would probably be unpalatable.

Ah, maybe I was brainwashed in the nineteen eighties. I should get to work. Take care,

Martin

Popular posts from this blog

The Congressional Healthcare Bill in America I spent a good deal of this morning and yesterday reading over the proposed American healthcare bill (or at least, a compound version; there appear to be five doing the rounds). I don't want to blog on the details of it immediately. It's also a bill, which may well stall in the Senate or be overtaken by events, and which could yet be critically amended. It is the product of Congress, not the administration per se, and the lawyers have not yet got at it. I had some instant worries about it though. In no particular order, I'll list them; Firstly, it can't allow individuals to choose their doctor and treatment in the long run; instead, it will practically formalise the role of doctors as salaried employees of large medical groups. Sarah Palin is onto something with the idea that this will then allow essentially ideological or non-medical outlooks on, say, euthanasia, abortion, transgender issues, or non-emergency treatments of c...
William Orpen There are four major Christian traditions, which are of course Catholic, Orthodox, Armenian and Coptic. Some sects and cults also exist, like the Moonies or Anglicanism. Yet in some bizarre way this weekend, protestant contributions to something other than the seizure of churches have been making their way into my consciousness. I suppose that the first indication of this trend was a reflection in an old copy of Gibbon that he actually became cultured because of Calvinism. Packed off to Switzerland because he went Catholic at an otherwise boring Oxford, Gibbon fell in love with Suzanne Cuchod, and with Greek because of instruction from a Calvinist mentor. It's an odd thing--I keep coming across indications of Calvinists who could have fun, though they doubtless thought that they would pay for it later, and whose political intelligence was second to none. Althusius springs to mind, for instance. But then what am I thinking, I thought to myself? I've sat on balconi...
Damon Buffini I'm not quite sure what to make of this story. Damon Buffini, a multi-millionaire in the City, and a very accomplished man, seems to have heard staff he regarded as lazy and ungrateful at the upper levels of management complaining about restaurants. He subsequently forced them all to eat two-day old Big Macs whilst reminding them of how lucky they are. It's nice to know that Saturn--in the form of a sort of globalisation guevara--could force his children to eat rather than devouring them, as in Goya's painting. How broken do people have to be not to walk out, though? I guess from his point of view, if they had any spine they'd be in business on their own. The whole thing is horribly fascinating.