
Can a Society Save Itself?
I love enterprising adventures. One of the things behind what one might call 'genuine' business is the way in which so much progress hangs upon optimism and the testing of recognised limits. Business can be grinding, depressing and pressurised, but, in the arena, with determination and often a little sharp practice, business can create jobs, test ideas and talk past the conformity required in settled operations. I've rarely met people as open minded as those who are in the arena, though the pressures upon them have, I know, led to pillowed tears and strain in not a few cases.
Enterprise has always seemed to me to be very lacking in the academic, public and corporate environments which we have created in the west. There's always a temptation to blame lawyers or economists for that, of course, but I think that the social sciences follow power and culture, not the other way around. The west grew up with the church's canons as public law, and when industry and the long French campaign against England and Austria resulted in the detonations of the eighteenth century, many were left looking for replacements for their mental scaffolding in ideas like progress or in an inflated understanding of science.
That inflation followed an obsession with a particular view of reason. It sought pathologically to prove the existence of material maxims for the life and meaning of a human being. Along the way, many good things were thrown off, but that obsessive question of what we could really ever understand led to the mad combinations of logical positivism, religious fundamentalism, and atheism that formed a tryptich for the late European mind. The Church's response was first to pose a counter-reforming platonic sensualism and mysticism that in truth was irrational, then to attempt to compromise by asserting a relativistic hierarchy of truth.
None of this actually inspires. Sometimes it leads to compromise with a cult of death, of Pelagian stupidity in the face of crime, in the refusal to set limits on individual behaviour or to discipline society. Sometimes it leads to the narcissism of Nixonland, where two over privileged sides fight manically over false gods, whilst the vast mass of people are sold out. Sometimes it leads to green pseudo-religions, the rational opponents of whom are met with cries of insanity.
When do we have reasonable solutions again? We are currently preparing to drown the west in inflated money. This would be the worst way of achieving a debt jubilee, because inflation destroys debts, at the same time as constraining narcissism. It's the other side of thinking that we can solve problems by dropping cruise missiles on people or sending patriotic men and women from working class communities to fight a battalion-size number of Muslim people from the same communities in a war in Afghanistan that has now spread to Pakistan, as predicted, or tear up Yugoslavia and call it liberty.
Class exists and is everywhere a reality. The aim of economic policy should be to create a world in which it is possible to own property and the fruits of one's labour in such a way that no one is forced by desperation to work for the present legions of the wealthy or the state. The aim of the state should be justice, and justice should be based on telling as few lies and propagating as much good as possible.
But all of this will now take enterprise, and utter determination, because it's easier to conform, easier to keep one's head down, and easier to fall for the junk-food philosophies churned out by the great and lesser universities of the west and across the media.
Comments