A Disgrace to EuropeThe painting is by Chris Peters and, rather ironically given the subject of this post, is called Leave the Shame Behind. I thought it an appropriate illustration. You can see more of Mr Peter's art here, and buy some if you wish.
I know that there is a very tangled history in the east. I know that Latvia suffered under Soviet tyranny, and I know that world war two was a very long time ago. But allowing the veterans and family of the Waffen SS to parade as though they were something other than the armies of the night and an eruption of the Satanic principle around Riga is, truly, beyond the pale.
However, I'm forced to ask myself what pale I would impose that would define the public sphere, and what my right to do so would be. Some in Latvia view this matter as one of free speech and assembly, and I can't think of an argument against them other than to tell them to just shut up and be ashamed--which might work in my head, but which may not in theirs.
I would support a first amendment for Europe (and all the other rights). I am a believer in free speech. I think that my religion reveals the way, the truth and the life, but that I can only ever seek to persuade and that, in any event, if God made us free so that we could choose it isn't up to anyone here to restrain choice beyond what is barely necessary for a good society to exist. Any faults will be weighed up in the round in infinity anyway, if I'm right, and if not it doesn't matter. We should have no 'choice' to kill ourselves or others; but we should every choice to speak, and to be wrong.
So, am I forced to say that I'd allow this sort of thing in the imaginary consistent world that I run in my head? It doesn't look to me like it is inciting a riot over there. The Latvian courts have banned it, but I can't find a report saying why. I'd be happy if the organisers were in jail, but by my own words, I'd stand exposed. For what would I jail them--their foetid words and actions? These people are celebrating the wartime racial nationalism of the murderers of at least 70,000 Jews in Latvia alone. They disgust me, but I am free to say that and so are their countrymen. That makes us, just in itself, better than them.
Why are people sometimes so bad and stupid, and what private force other than religion can ever make them obey voluntary limits of decency? Don't tell me reason works with everyone. Family? Tradition?
I was appalled by those men screaming lies against the Anglian Regiment in Luton the other week. But, in a sense, it was a mark of the civilisation of this country that they were allowed to do so. I know how that sounds, and that many think that the right of free expression stops when it causes offence--when people go on the Labour list website tonight, for instance, and suggest a slogan for the British Conservatives such as 'my son's dead, vote Dave'.
But it can't. It isn't spineless to defend free speech legally in these circumstances, it isn't weak to say that society should shun or shame those who talk like that but shouldn't gag them with the same laws that guarantee our freedom. There are already too many things people are not allowed to say, by law.
I remember a story some American friends of mine related about Muslim taxi drivers in Holland. They didn't talk about a Europe where anyone who wanted to say anything against them publicly was silenced, whilst at the same time locking them into particular areas and identities and jobs behind community 'leaders' who were either savages or liars; they talked about countries where people were free, and especially about America. How many hate-filled, frustrated American Muslims are there anymore? I'm sure readers could show me some, but I could show you more who are just getting on with their lives. They can there.
Freedom brings responsibility; responsibility implies duty; the breach of duty to civilisation, which is what supporting Nazis or hate or racial nonsense is, should imply shame. Not jail. It's what my granny used to do when Orangemen walked down the street, according to family lore; put up a statue of our lady and pray for their benighted souls.
That said, I tell you this, when I see this sort of thing, in Latvia or Luton, or Trafalgar Square I agree with Mary Robinson.
And--at the risk of spoiling the mood-- before anyone gets any ideas, this is my blog. If you don't like what I say, or can't disagree with respect and under your own name, get your own free blog and quote me, because I moderate comments here. Here's Charlie Chaplin, again, on what you dream of people saying one day.
Comments