The Hispanic community in the
On top of this apparent
confusion, the nature of ‘civil rights’ is also apt to confuse. For instance,
most modern civil rights flow from Congress, as it takes up its duty to explain
the meaning of the thirteenth, fourteenth and fifteenth amendments to the
constitution with legislation such as the Equal Opportunities Act and the
Voting Rights Act. The Constitution of the United States contains no general
provision for human rights, nor any provision for non-citizens, and is of
course a document that regulates and limits a federal body. The ‘due process of
the laws’, and the fourteenth amendments emphasis on the federalization of the
bill of rights in many but not all instances to bind the states, only applies
to citizens born or naturalized in the United States.
Nevertheless, on
examination, four major abuses of the Hispanic community in general can be
discerned, which required a legal response that had to be based on civil
rights. Firstly, the use of people as immigrant labour, to be exploited and
discarded, was a matter of concern right through the period, from the
employment of Vaqueros in Texas and the southwest through the Bracero programme
of world war two, to the actions undertaken in ‘operation wetback’ in the
1950s. Because people who either entered or were employed in the United States did so under a Treaty with mexico over the
border, then the behaviour of the federal government towards them was
reviewable by the Supreme Court. In reviewing how they were treated, the court
could have read a civil right to fair treatment or to non-discrimination into
federal behaviour, particularly since some of those affected could have been
American citizens or the parents of American citizens. That it did not do so
was probably a result of prevailing attitudes in society towards Hispanics,
coupled with a judicial restraint.
The Supreme Court did
attempt to deal with a second abuse of the Hispanic community, which occurred
as segregation struck at young Americans who wised to study in white schools. In
court cases such as Menendez, the
court ruled that, for the purposes of segregation, Hispanics were white, not
black, and in a small way, dealt with educational discrimination. It would be
difficult to treat this as the most significant of the discriminations faced by
the Hispanic community, however.
A third set of civil
rights that were important to Hispanics were those that tended to restrain the
police in States and which affected the courts at federal and state level. A
person charged or tried has, the court decided in the nineteen sixties, the
right to a lawyer, to fair rules of evidence, to a reading of their rights, and
to due process of law leading to a fair trial before a jury. These are civil
rights grounded in the first, fourth, fifth, eighth and fourteenth amendments
to the constitution. It is striking, though probably coincidental, that the
Supreme Court chose to uncover and regenerate them after a great deal of
neglect in the Miranda v Arizona case. Though
this case affected ethnic minorities in particular, and all citizens in
general, it is not of course ‘an Hispanic case’, especially since to call it
such would tar people by association. Miranda was a deeply unsavoury character
who could never have become a rallying point, although racists tried to make
him so.
Though access to justice
and fair treatment were important—arguably more so than the political right to
organize a party like La Raza Unida by 1972 in Texas , for instance—the fourth, key civil
right for Hispanics in the period was probably the right to organize trade
unions and to strike.
Hispanic advances in the
twentieth century did not begin with marches on Washington , except indirectly. They began,
in Texas, Florida and California, with the determination of individuals such as
Cesar Chavez to protect the interests and working condition of itinerant
lettuce-growers, and fruit-pickers, and others performing back-breaking labour
for the ultimate benefit of America’s new supermarkets and convenience stores.
This entailed the exercise of civil rights that could not be restricted to
citizens alone, such as the right to withdraw labour, the right to make political
coalitions and to trade votes with people associated with the 1968 Kennedy
campaign and the 1972 McGovern one, and the right to accumulate funds and to
call legally for boycotts of particular goods or suppliers. Collateral to these
rights were the right to access state welfare and driving licence systems on
the presumption of legal status or citizenship, and the right not to suffer
undue punishment if found to be an illegal immigrant but to be subject to a
proper legal process.
On all of these rights,
the American political system ‘delivered’. It is noticeable that Hispanics used
them more than African-Americans, even though Martin Luther King and Ralph
Abernathy attempted to give a poor workers’ direction to the Civil Rights
movement after 1965. It is also noticeable that they were key to Hispanic
success in the United States ,
more than an attempt (comparable to that of the more successful Natice
Americans) to encourage Spanish-language laws or affirmative action or the
development of community enclaves.
However, it is also
apparent that moves to organize Hispanic trade union power ultimately only
dealt with a serious, indeed mortal, aspect of the Hispanic experience, which
was exploitation within various labour systems. These moves did not regularize
the status of immigrants, and lead to amnesty of longstanding illegal
immigrants; nor did they regularize the status of Puerto
Rico , which took congressional action; nor did they alter the
abandonment of Cuban and Mexicano communities to ‘community leaders’ often with
an agenda of exclusive and limiting identity politics comparable to those of
black nationalists.
These things were dealt
with politically, and in part by the social and economic mobility of the United States , They ran alongside the fact that
many immigrants were prepared to enter the US illegally and make its low costs
and supply chains possible regardless of rights or the law. They also altered
with the separate and fissile nature of Hispanic urban integration at the end
of the period, as some groups embraced education, affirmative action, or
economic mobility and moved into the American mainstream. The Hispanic
experience was therefore distinct, but distinguished in part by the civil
rights relating to labour; and that is why they were the most important civil
right for the Hispanic community.
Comments